UK & Europe | Investigations & Public Interest
Telling survivor truths. Protecting sources. Holding cults to account.
Transcript: Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters hearing, 16 October 2026

This is a verbatim transcript of the public hearing of the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters on 16 October 2026, made from the audio of the hearing. Each timestamp links to that moment in the video of the hearing on YouTube (3 hours 11 minutes).
The audio was transcribed by several speech-recognition systems, and disputed words and speakers were checked by listening. Where people spoke over each other, the voices were separated and transcribed one at a time. Speakers are named where their voice could be matched with high certainty; otherwise they are shown as “Unidentified speaker”. The few passages where the words could not be made out are marked as crosstalk or unclear.
The Parliament has published the official Proof Committee Hansard for this hearing (PDF). Hansard is edited for readability, while this transcript records what was said. The main differences are:
- repetitions, false starts and self-corrections, which Hansard removes;
- interruptions, interjections and points of order spoken over others, which Hansard often leaves out or shortens;
- grammar left as it was spoken, where Hansard tidies it.
We checked every difference against the audio and used Hansard to fill gaps where the audio supports it; where they still differ, this transcript follows the audio.

Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:09:51
Public hearing of the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters for the Inquiry into the federal election. In accordance with the Committee's resolution of 4 August 2025, this hearing will be broadcast on the Parliament's website and the proof and official transcripts of proceedings will be published on the Parliament's website. I remind members of the media who may be present or listening online. Of the need to fairly and accurately report the proceedings of this committee. I now welcome Mr. Bruce Hales to give evidence today. For the Hansard record, sir, would you please state your full name and the capacity in which you appear before the committee.

Bruce Hales
0:10:29
Bruce David Hales. I'm appearing here as the senior leader of the Brethren, worldwide.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:10:40
Thank you very much, Mr Hales. Although the committee does not require to give evidence under oath, I should advise you that this hearing is a legal proceeding of the parliament and therefore has the same standing as the proceedings of respective houses. The giving of false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be regarded as a contempt of parliament. The evidence given today will be recorded by Hansard and attracts parliamentary privilege. I now invite you to make a brief opening statement before we proceed to discussion
Bruce Hales
0:11:11
Very good. Thank you, Mr Chair, and Deputy Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to make a short opening statement. I have accepted the committee's invitation to appear today and thank you for allowing me to do so via AVL. I acknowledge the work of this committee and its inquiry into the 2025 federal election.
On 5 October 2026, I wrote to the committee of my own volition, I set out the questions I understood the committee to be interested in and answered each of them in detail. I did so to assist the committee to understand the extent of my knowledge with respect to the issues that have preoccupied the committee. Those answers demonstrate that I had no involvement in the alleged activities of members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church during the 2025 federal election.
I stand by those answers and will refer to them during the course of my evidence I have a copy of my letter here, with me today, and if you have any questions about the matters raised in my letter, I would be grateful if you could direct me to the relevant paragraph.
If you have any questions about other issues which are not covered by my letter... but are relevant to the terms of reference, I would be happy to answer those also. Despite this letter, I was threatened with a summons if I did not appear before the committee in an effort to hold me to. Account for the political beliefs and alleged actions of church members.
To assist the committee I will address three key themes from my letter. Personally, my role in the church. I am recognised by members as the most senior elder of the church globally. The church has no formal hierarchy, no clergy and no appointed ministers. No one appointed me and no one voted for me. There is no office to hold or resign.
My role is spiritual. I give guidance so that members can live by the principles of the Holy Bible. This includes at times providing practical advice about personal matters such as relationships, housing, job selection and career advice. I'm not a director of and hold no office in the company that performs the church's administrative work. I also have no authority over and do not seek to influence, members' political choices, their businesses, or how they take part, in civic life.
Secondly I had no involvement in the 2025 federal election. I want to be clear and unequivocal. I had no involvement whatsoever in relation to any members who volunteered or took part in any aspect of the 2025 federal election, I did not plan such activities, I did not coordinate such activities, I did not direct such activities,. I did not fund such activities. This could not have been stated more clearly in my letter, the church does not engage in any political activity, and if members do so, they do so in their personal capacity.
I had no agreement or understanding with the Liberal Party or any political party or with any group or person involved in the 2025 federal election. I made no donation, payment or contribution to anyone. I do not commission or pay for advertising of any kind. What I know of our members' participation I primarily learnt from the media.
I do not agree with the harassment or intimidation of anyone, and my genuine sympathy goes to anyone who felt intimidated at the 2025 federal election. If anti-social acts were committed by any individual of any faith they should answer what they did, I cannot answer for them.
Finally, I ask you to consider the role of the Church, the individual conscience of its members and our right to religious freedom. Our fellowship is not a test of political conscience. No member's place in our fellowship depends on how they vote, which party they support or whether they campaign or volunteer at elections.
Our member votes and whether they take any part in political life either by themselves or with other church members is a matter of their own conscience before God. It is not a matter for me and it is not a matter for the church. Neither the church nor I direct or control members' political activities, which, if they are conducted, are conducted in their private capacity. I do not control the lives of our members and not, nor do I seek to do so.
My role is to guide members to lead their lives in accordance with the scriptural principles as set out in the Holy Bible and the teachings and writings of the Church. Members do not need anyone's approval to take part in political activity. The Church keeps no register of members' political activities, there is no command structure directing them, and there is no person in the Church who can answer for them.
The Church is a religious organisation, not a political one. Our members, like members of any other faith in Australia, are entitled to take part in the political process, including by volunteering in their personal capacity. I do not personally do this and nor do I encourage others to do so.
However, the church should not be targeted for our members' exercising this right. I'm deeply concerned that members of our faith feel that they cannot exercise their political rights due to the prospect of retribution against their church or senior church members. If members of any organisation who routinely come together, whether that is as part of a business, an association, a charity, or even a church, decide to undertake a political activity together, that organisation is not responsible for their actions, nor is its leader. I ask the committee to reconsider whether it is appropriate that a faith leader of our church should be asked to account for the political choices of private individuals who share his faith.
The same would not be asked or expected from senior members of other faiths. Nonetheless I'm here to... assist the committee. I will do my best to answer your questions but I cannot answer a question fully today. I will provide a subsequent written response. Thank you.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:17:52
Thank you Mr Hales just so we all know members we're pretty tight The same would not be asked or expected from senior Minister, and I'll go to the Deputy Chair, Senator Colbeck.

Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:18:05
Thanks, Chair. Can I just start by requesting that Mr. Hales opening statement be tabled, please?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:18:12
I think it has been sent to the secretariat. We're happy to table that or provide a copy to members of the committee, yep, And it will be recorded in Hansard as well, Senator Colbeck.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:18:25
No, no, well I would like to have it distributed if we can, so that I can, I would like to refer to it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:18:31
Thank you.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:18:32
Can I first, Mr Hales,. Go to some comments that you've been reported to have made with respect to the Jewish community? They were raised at, I think, the last healing hearings with Mr Grimshaw reported in the media. I mean, it's a matter of concern to me. I'd be curious to get an understanding of the context of those reported comments.
Bruce Hales
0:19:06
Yes, so when were those comments made, which ones are you referring to?
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:19:14
Look, I think they go back a little while. They were made, as a part of one of your broadcasts. They were certainly referred to in our first hearings, while. Previous hearing with Mr. Grimshaw. He made some provided some response to that, but I was curious broadcasts. Get your context around those particular comments.
Bruce Hales
0:19:40
Yes, that's understandable. I have great respect for the Jewish faith, and I don't believe I've ever said anything other than that, ever, but I myself came from a Jewish family in England. So that at times when the Jewish, there's been a reference to what's Jewish, it's been possibly in a lighter vein But not, certainly, in any connection of being against the Jews or against their religion, I have my own judgment of their code and but we do actually pray regularly for the Israel nation because of the terrible conflict that's going on there and we respect their views. So I don't really know to be director of it, in what the context was of the remarks.
Just try and look through the correspondence I've got here, if I can find anything directly related to it, but I know that it's come up, but I do know that at certain times it was, as I said, in what I'd call a lighter vein, if that makes sense,
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:21:40
Well, I'd be curious to understand what you mean by that, and I'm not sure whether they were readings from. I'm not sure. Well, I'm not sure whether they were readings from the Bible or something of that nature that were part of your broadcast, but I'd be curious to understand. I ask about the context. The comments have been reported, obviously, as part of various newspaper stories referred to in our last hearing, but I would like to understand what the broader context of those is. As I said before,. It's a matter of interest and concern for me.
Bruce Hales
0:22:21
Yes, well anyone familiar with the holy scriptures would know that, especially in the four Gospels, St Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, that the Jews aren't exactly referred to favourably because they were the ones that finally clamoured publicly for Christ to be crucified, which of course as we all know was carried out. The Lord himself was a Jew.
The Apostle Paul, whose writings we go very much by, he was a very devout Jew before he got converted by a corporeal appearing of Christ on the Damascus Road. That's another story detailed first in the Book of the Acts. Chapter nine. So, there's quite a bit of a history, you might say, to the Jewish matter or the Jewish question.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:23:40
Okay. In terms of your legal role within the church, what is your legal role within the church?
Bruce Hales
0:23:52
Well, legal role, the only reference to me this point in time that I know of is in one of the trustees, someone should better give that to me, it refers to whether anyone is can be vouched to be a member of the Plymouth Brethren. The general test for being a member of the Plymouth Brethren is that they are admitted to and take part at the Lord's Su Supper, which is our holy communion conducted every Sunday morning.
But when it comes down to an actual person, and as far as I know, I haven't ever been asked to decide on this, then I have the final word as to whether they are in fact a member of the Plymouth Brethren or not. But apart from that, unless I'm missing something, legally, I have no authority in writing apart from what has been accorded to me by members of the church unanimously and indeed somewhat spontaneously.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:25:35
Last question, Mr Colbeck, and I'm happy to come back to you. We've got time at the end.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:25:39
Okay, thank you. So you're not a director of the church in that sense?
Bruce Hales
0:25:44
I'm not, I hold no official office or title.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:25:54
Thanks, Deputy Chair. I might now go to Ms Campbell.

Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:25:59
Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Mr Hales, for appearing before the committee today. I just wanted to start by asking, you give sermons weekly, that's correct, yes?
Bruce Hales
0:26:14
Yes, we have meetings on the weekend especially that I attend, Saturday and Sunday, which we call Lord's Day, and they take the form of Bible readings, which go for about an hour, and I suggest the subject or the scriptures to read, and then the members of the congregation come in and participate and then we do have gospel sermons on a regular basis every Sunday. We have them in the main, as far as I'm speaking for myself, the main city church at Ermington, and then we have others in the smaller gospel halls, which in Sydney is about 20, 30, throughout the afternoon.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:27:14
Thank you for that. So Essentially on this weekly basis, you talk to all the people who are members of the Brethren. How are those sermons distributed?
Bruce Hales
0:27:30
They are recorded and then they're published centrally in London by the Bible and Gospel Tract Trust.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:27:47
So what you say to the members is recorded, distributed out to everyone and then how are they interpreted in the lives of your followers? Are they discussed? Are they challenged? Are they studied?
Bruce Hales
0:28:02
Well, they're most likely or more likely a subject of interest and can also provide a subject matter for various and many church meetings that occur throughout the global situation at the Brethren churches.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:28:28
The interpretations of those sermons that you give, do you discuss those with your senior leadership within the church?
Bruce Hales
0:28:36
No, because what I say at any of those readings, just call them a reading, that's when we read the Bible and then discuss the particular scriptures. They're not pre-scripted, and what I say I get at the time, and they're not discussed afterwards because it just goes on from week to week. And there are many and sorry, excuse me, and there are many other readings taken by other elders, so that there's quite a good deal of currency of conversation.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:29:21
So what what you say in those in that forum and that distribution to you know far and wide do you think any of that would ever be misinterpreted?
Bruce Hales
0:29:37
Yes at times yes but I leave that up to individual persons to interpret what they see and feel that I mean but very very rarely do I have to go back and explain what I meant by what I said.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:30:01
So you very rarely have to go back and explain so you know you're a long-standing member of the church you know essentially if if you very rarely have to go back it's clear what you say in when you say those words.
Bruce Hales
0:30:14
So I think it'd be fair to say that it's clear in the main what I say, yes.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:30:18
Okay. Thank you. In your submission, part B in paragraph 10. You say that you led a Bible reading as you do, as you've said every week, and you describe that sermon as a worship and a call to prayer. I think this is the 20th of April 2025. Was that sermon broadcast any differently to your regular broadcast?
Bruce Hales
0:30:45
No, it wasn't. I'm just looking at it now. Did you say it comes up in question 11?
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:30:52
It's. In Part B, paragraph 10 of your submission.
Bruce Hales
0:30:59
Oh, yes. On April 25, I observed the state of the world and I appealed to the congregation to be more fervent and prepared for good government and benefit of all Australians and I said Australia needed to be happy again, smiling again.
Well that was a form of words that I thought up at the time so it was not something that I planned to say but I was aware by reading the media and by various discussions that I had from members of the public from time to time that there was a certain amount of discontent as I viewed it with the present government and that expression, happy again and smiling again, I can't quite accurately recall where I would have got that expression. There was a song on the Australian radio some many years ago as to, What's it called again?
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:32:20
That's okay, that's okay. I was gonna say, that's okay. That's okay, you know, it's it is it is a phrase that I haven't heard before, but very specifically that phrase happy again, smiling again, was in that sermon. The other thing that you said in that sermon was, for people to be fervent in their prayers. What did you mean by fervent in their prayers?
Bruce Hales
0:32:44
Fervent in the prayer means that there is it a degree perhaps of urgency. I am concerned about the government of Australia. Respect the government as such irrespective of the political party that's in power at any particular time. But I respect government very much and look up to government and hold government in very respectful light. At any particular time.

Senator Bridget McKenzie
0:33:18
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
It's Senator McKenzie. I've been in many Catholic churches and Anglican churches where the weekly prayers are for our country and for I look up to I'm just not sure how this actually refers to the term.

Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:33:33
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
Can we have some order here at the moment please? I don't know why we have Senators jumping in across questioning witnesses... Sorry, Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:33:42
Yeah, no, Senator McKenzie, we're prioritising members of this committee to ask questions. I'm happy with the questions being within the terms of reference. I think Ms Campbell can continue. I'm happy to come to you at the end. So if you could please save your comments till then. Thank you. Thank you.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:33:56
So when you talk about fervent in their prayers, sorry, Mr Hales, you were talking about that in relation to government and the concerns that you have about government, yes?
Bruce Hales
0:34:10
It's just generally, when we pray... at our weekly prayer meetings and indeed at the opening and closing of every church session, government is prayed for but no particular names in the government would be mentioned, nor, I don't believe any, any political parties. It would be that we pray for government, might do what's right and God because we're a Christian country and I think that's what the government should be. Going by is Christianity.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:34:54
In your opening statement, you said a few things. You said, I do guidance. You said, I provide advice. And you said that you said the phrase, lead their lives. Later on, while we've been talking here, you said that your sermons are very rarely misinterpreted, and that it's clear what you mean by the words that you say. So when you said those words fervent in their prayers, and when you said Australia needs to be happy again, smiling again, based on your evidence, if those things are not misinterpreted and those things are clear, what do you think people took from them?
Bruce Hales
0:35:41
I don't know, except to take the words as they came out. As I've just said, I can't exactly recollect the origin of those words I used, but I'm just going back to you. Are you referring to what I've said in... letter that I just read out or something else?
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:36:14
I was referring to the Bible reading that you did on, in Part B, Paragraph 10 of your submission to the committee.
Bruce Hales
0:36:25
got that, but you were referring to something else, weren't you?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:36:26
You said your opening statement.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:36:28
Your opening statement. Sorry, in your opening statement you said, I do guidance. You said that you provide advice to your followers.
Bruce Hales
0:36:35
I'm just trying to find that. Sorry. Sorry.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:36:38
That's okay. And then in the questions that we were just talking about then, you said that very rarely were your words misinterpreted, and you said it's clear to them what they meant.
Bruce Hales
0:36:51
When I spoke in the... opening statement as to giving guidance. I'm just trying to find the section, but That would be mostly private private advice and private, sorry, I just can't find it or I said that.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:37:19
My notes say I do guidance. But Mr Hales, I'm cognisant that I've only got one question left. So, My final question was going to be, did you discuss the context of your sermon, that sermon with your sons Gareth Charles and Dean and the interpretation of that with your sons, given your testimony?
Bruce Hales
0:37:44
No I didn't. I believe they were present and in general I would never discuss the content of my readings or sermons with my sons.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:37:59
Because if you said, as you said, your meaning would be clear.
Bruce Hales
0:38:02
Generally it would be. Generally, understood, yes.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
0:38:05
Thank you very much, I appreciate it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:38:07
Thank you Ms Campbell, Dr Ryan.

Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:38:09
Thank you very much. Mr Hales, you said in your submission to the inquiry that you described yourself as the church's most senior elder globally. You've done that again this morning. And you've said this morning that no one appointed you. How is it that you came to attain that position?
Bruce Hales
0:38:31
Well, I travelled widely overseas. My first trip overseas was 1972, so that I was known well globally by many, many individuals in the church and indeed I visited and have now visited every congregation worldwide. I was known and I was known as respected.
It's interesting you say that because just yesterday I was thinking after coming back from the burial of my father in January 2002 and thinking of the fact that the responsibility for the church globally now fell on my shoulders and then indeed within, a very short period of time, the phone started ringing from various Brethren around the globe. So that it's a bit hard for me, but it was a spontaneous acceptance of me as the leader so that I was respected, looked up to, I was known and I think they felt that I was carrying, I was one to be able to carry the leadership on authoritatively and carry the confidence of all the members of the congregations.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:40:09
So a spontaneous decision made by 56,000 members of the church, is that right?
Bruce Hales
0:40:15
That's right, exactly that.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:40:16
Thank you. Your father though, John. Stephen Hales, preceded you as head of the Church. Is it true that you did you once say of him that he was a sanctified vessel that put you in touch directly with Christ?
Bruce Hales
0:40:34
I don't know, but I believe it's true. I think he was a holy man of God. I don't hesitate to say that he was ahead of me spiritually and he definitely will be in touch with the Lord Jesus Christ as our Savior.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:40:52
Thank you. Do members of the church refer to you as the elect vessel?
Bruce Hales
0:40:57
No, they don't and I don't accept that title. I believe I've said publicly that that title, in my view, belonged to the Apostle Paul, which was given to him by the Lord, when the Lord was giving instructions to Ananias in regard of having to do with Saul of Tarsus, and that's where that expression is used exclusively.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:41:27
Okay, thank you. Do members of the church believe that you are a direct messenger from God?
Bruce Hales
0:41:35
Well I would think that they would say that what I get I get from the Lord.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:41:47
Is it true the church members look to you for guidance with respect to where they live,. What house they can buy, who and when they marry, where and what they study, what career they can pursue, whether they can own pets, their clothes and hairstyle, including the ability to bear facial hair, what places of entertainment they can go to and what holidays and travel they can undertake?
Bruce Hales
0:42:16
No.

Ben Small MP
0:42:17
Just a point of order on this one, Chair, like I'm happy to entertain other members' questions but this is so far off the terms of reference for this inquiry. I mean, the mechanics of the church and understanding leadership structures, sure, but this is patently ridiculous.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:42:36
I'll allow it, but I'll ask
Senator Bridget McKenzie
0:42:37
Hairstyles have no bearing on electoral matters.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:42:39
Thank you, thank you. I'll allow it, but I'll ask Dr Ryan to
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:42:43
Alright. Let me ask you this. Mr Hales, can members publicly disagree with your ministry and your teachings and remain in the full fellowship of your church?
Bruce Hales
0:42:54
Yes they can. I allow for other views, or views other than my own and I would say that I'm sympathetic with different views and give them credit. When credit is due, I give them credit.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:43:18
Your position that members can openly challenge your decisions during church meetings?
Bruce Hales
0:43:24
Yes, if they wish to, absolutely.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:43:27
Okay, we've heard from a number of...
Bruce Hales
0:43:32
It would be rare because of, in general, they would respect me and respect what I say, but no, certainly I'm open to criticism and look, the Brethren know that and I get letters that challenge certain things that I've said and I don't hesitate to answer up to them.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:44:01
One of the questions is that members who have made submissions or former members of the church who have made submissions to this inquiry say that members of the church believe that your ministry carries spiritual or divine authority and that that being the case, it's not possible for members of the church to distinguish between something Bruce Hales personally favours or something that they should and need to understand that God requires of them. Are you able to address that question? Look,
Bruce Hales
0:44:33
I don't know what correspondence you're referring to specifically but there are persons that have gone and left the Fellowship and some of them, only a fairly small percentage have become sort of what we would say in opposition to us and again they're entitled to their views but what you're asking me now, I don. No, I can't agree with that.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:45:06
Okay, thank you. Is it possible that something that you might say, for example during your ministries, result in similar action occurring across a number of congregations without you ever issuing a formal instruction?
Bruce Hales
0:45:24
Well, Dr Ryan, I think people get something I say in church, in the church reading or a sermon and then they go and expand on it or repeat it or promote it I wouldn't necessarily know at all when that's occurring and secondly again I've said they're entitled to their own view, and if they express it well it's up to the congregation where they are and where that's been said, as to how they judge it.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:46:05
Okay. Thanks, Mr Hales.
Ben Small MP
0:46:06
Chair, I'm at about eight minutes of this, so whose time is this coming up?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:46:10
Yeah, I gave her
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:46:11
the round of this, the last question,
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:46:12
and there were interruptions, Mr Small, and everyone's gone over including the witness. So last question.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:46:19
Last question. Thank you very much. Mr Hales, I'd like to return to the question that Senator Colbeck raised earlier regarding the question of your attitude to the Jewish faith. Do you deny that in a 2020 ministry you spoke of what you called the Jewish question and said that the sin of killing Christ was, and I quote, fixed on the Jews and that you referred to the domination of the Jewish people by the devil?
Bruce Hales
0:46:51
Yes, well, I'd have to look at the context of that, Dr Ryan, but I go by the record of the Bible, especially the four Gospels, and the accounts that are given there by those writers as to the trial of Jesus before the Governor, Pontius Pilate, and the confession that Christ made himself personally that's recorded and then leading on to his crucifixion. So that's what I would primarily go by and be governed by.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
0:47:29
Thanks Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:47:30
Thank you Dr Ryan. Senator Mulholland.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:47:33
Thank you Chair and thank you Mr Hales for joining us. In your opening statement this morning you have said that you had no involvement in the 2025 federal election. You didn't plan, you didn't coordinate, you didn't fund any activities and you also make this statement in paragraph 22 in your submission.
There are a number of media reports relating to your sermon which has been discussed in Ms Campbell's evidence relating to what you told members that Australia need to smile again, and off the back of that, recording your sons produced a recording that was sent out to members where they said, quoted, that we need to make sure our booths are manned and our volunteers are fired up each day. Can you explain to the committee what that relates to?
Bruce Hales
0:48:30
I can't, because I had nothing to do with those words. I did not know that those words have supposedly been uttered and you I haven't seen the correspondence in which it applies to but they certainly didn't come from my lips.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:48:47
What I'll do is I'll give you, and you're most welcome to look this up at your own leisure, the news article Exclusive Brethren don't Vote But A Secretly Campaigning for the Coalition, the 28th of April 2025. The direct quotes of your sons are in that article so if you want to make yourself aware of that material, you're happy to look it up at your leisure. Further I just want to go through the timelines here. I I'm on limited time so I'm going. I'm going to keep moving. On the 13th of April you are recorded as saying, make Australia smile again.
And off the back of that recording, your sons are then recorded and sent out to membership talking about manning booths and also having their volunteers fired up. Now you're saying you can't recollect, you said it earlier, origin of that statement, but what we also have are media articles where it is reported and shown photos of that very statement being used on electronic billboards placed in marginal seats across New South Wales.
In the same location where there are numbers of Brethren in large numbers at pre-polling booths, within two weeks of your sermon, standing there in unprecedented numbers, alongside billboards and signage on the back of trucks, they make Australia smile again. And your evidence to this committee is that you have no recollection, no causal link, no knowledge of how that occurred.
Bruce Hales
0:50:22
No, and it might seem extraordinary…
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:50:25
It does, it does seem extraordinary.
Bruce Hales
0:50:28
Exactly, and I can understand how you might find it hard to believe, but the fact is that I had no knowledge of those events before, and no, what's the word, part in planning them, and look, I think if they'd asked me about them, and asked permission, I would have denied it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:50:53
Why would they...
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:50:54
So you think that your sons deliberately didn't ask you about it?
Bruce Hales
0:50:57
Quite likely.
Ben Small MP
0:50:59
Er, hold up, hold up, Chair. What sort of hypothetical nonsense are we are getting into here?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:04
It's a valid line of questioning, Mr Small.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:06
Ms Mulholland, please continue.
Ben Small MP
0:51:07
How is that a valid line of questioning under
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:10
Yeah,
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:10
Mr Small, you'll have your time shortly.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
0:51:14
This is not the Spanish Inquisition, Chair. This is ridiculous.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:18
Ms Mulholland.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
0:51:18
It's a lot like religious persecution to me.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:22
Ms Mulholland.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:24
Sorry, just before you go, Ms Mulholland, you said why would your sons need, to ask you for permission to do something like that?. Mr Hales? You say,
Unidentified speaker
0:51:36
why would they?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:37
Yeah, you said if they'd asked me for permission to would they ask you for permission to do, to participate in the election. Okay. All right. You. No, they didn't. Yeah, Miss Mulholland?
Bruce Hales
0:51:49
them.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:51:49
Okay, Ms. Mulholland.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:51:52
We will have an opportunity next.
Bruce Hales
0:51:53
I'm strong-minded and fairly independent.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:51:57
Yeah, what I... The terms of reference of this committee are not about religious freedoms and not about religious discrimination as much as other members of this committee
Senator Bridget McKenzie
0:52:07
Clearly, not about religious freedom because this
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:52:10
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
is, an hour, nothing to do with patterns. Sorry, sorry Senator
Senator Bridget McKenzie
0:52:18
Mulholland.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:52:19
Senator McKenzie, you are not a permanent member of this committee and you've done nothing but interrupt other members of this committee during their questioning. I would respectfully ask you to cease doing that, As I said, I will come to you for your questions and comments at the end. If time permits, I'll ask you that you exercise some restraint, please. Senator Mulholland.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:52:47
Thank you, Chair. So, as I was saying, this isn't about religious discrimination, this is about the involvement in election, and we have processes and places for third parties to disclose their involvement. So, off the back of what you now know is involvement of members of your family in talking about our booths, our volunteers firing up, being involved in the election campaign. Do you see this as being involvement in the election campaign from your family
Bruce Hales
0:53:22
I don't know what you're referring to specifically. I've got, four boys, four sons, and do act independently of me, and they do have various meetings and consultations completely apart and without my participation. Now that's why I was asking before when you were quoting some script as to where is that taken from? Is that from a newspaper or?
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:54:00
So that's from the 13th of April, 13th of 2025 sermon and it's from that article that I gave you, the link to, the 28th of April 2025, so a couple of weeks after you gave your sermon and was distributed by your sons Gareth, Charles and Dean, they are quoted in the recording as saying, make sure our booths are manned and our volunteers are fired up each day in relation to the campaign.
Bruce Hales
0:54:27
That's not accurate. Sorry Senator, but that's not accurate.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:54:32
Explain to me why it's not accurate.
Bruce Hales
0:54:34
Well, are you saying that you're actually quoting from a transcript of a recording?
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:54:43
I'm saying I'm saying that it has been reported in this article. That is what your son said.
Bruce Hales
0:54:47
The article is incorrect.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:54:49
Well, it's also in your attachment Mr Hales, where you've said on the 20th of April 2025, I appealed to the congregation to be more fervent in prayer for good government and I said Australia needed to be happy again.
And then those same words were in a media article on the 28th of April which then includes an interpretation of your sermon where your sons have interpreted that sermon and elements of it to make sure our boos are manned and volunteers are fired up every day to keep up the ground game. I mean, To me it's clear that your sons interpreted your sermon as an instruction to campaign where interpretations are rarely wrong. Do you accept that your sermon was interpreted as an instruction to campaign?
Bruce Hales
0:55:49
No, The other thing is, I Is that what you're quoting, those two statements about? Sorry, put the finger on them. The two statements as to... do giving the booze manned, I think there was, and there was another one in conjunction with that, that I certainly never used those words and I don't recall them ever being used publicly or privately.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:56:33
I'm not saying that you use those words, Mr Hales. I think the version of events is you gave your—
Ben Small MP
0:56:39
Well, Chair, we're now at 10 minutes of Labor questioning just from this.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:56:44
There's a lot of interruptions, Mr Small, so we're going ahead with.
Ben Small MP
0:56:48
The importance of latitude, the bringing points of standing orders is not an unacceptable interruption. It is in-fact in line with the Senate standing orders on which we are conducting this inquiry.
Unidentified speaker
0:56:59
He's burning up time.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:57:00
Thank you Mr Small, I'm asking a question as the Chair. So, your
Ben Small MP
0:57:05
So, whose time is that coming from?
Unidentified speaker
0:57:06
Mute him.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:57:07
I'm happy to cede my time to the Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:57:09
Thank you.

Andrew Gee MP
0:57:10
It's just out of order.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
0:57:11
a big... so many times to come by Mr Small and Mr Nancy.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:57:18
On the 20th of April in your own words you led a Bible reading that your congregation need to be more fervent in prayer for good government and needed to be happy again. I refer to paragraph 10 of your letter to the committee.
It was then reported that your sons did a video message which was then converted into a text message. How awesome was it to hear that recording on GMS. We should be freshly charged and motivated to give this all we've got, you know, and I'm paraphrasing in the interest of time, make sure our booths are manned, it's all in the extra 1%, keep up the ground game. So, again, was your was your prayer interpreted incorrectly or was it interpreted correctly?
Bruce Hales
0:58:08
Don't you think that what you're quoting that must have been said privately. I have no, I've never been, I never heard that before. Those words, which you were saying now as following on, supposedly the reading on the 20th of 25. I've never heard those before. I'm sorry.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:58:30
I'm the 20th of they're your words from your statement, fervent in prayer, Australia need to be happy again.
Bruce Hales
0:58:38
You said there were certain things that were said publicly after that.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:58:45
It was a video recording that was reported in the paper, that said How awesome was it to hear that recording, your recording?
Bruce Hales
0:58:53
That's the first I've heard of it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:58:54
That's the first you've heard of it. The first you've heard of it.
Bruce Hales
0:58:56
I've first heard of it Thank you. And I don't have the source of those words, whether they're true or accurate, I wouldn't know. Who is the writer of the article?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:09
Mr Michael Bachelard.
Bruce Hales
0:59:10
Yeah, well, in that case, I would question the validity and accuracy of what he's reporting.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:17
Are you saying the reporting is inaccurate?
Ben Small MP
0:59:20
Hang on. Again, Chair, at what point do I get to ask a question or at least another member of the Coalition?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:25
You're up next, Mr Small. I'm going government, non-government. I've got this here and you're next. There are members of the non-government that aren't members of the Coalition, Mr Small.
Ben Small MP
0:59:37
[indecipherable] We've had one of them.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:41
Yes, and the next one is you. So if...
Ben Small MP
0:59:44
So, I know, we're at like the twelfth minute of what was supposed to be a 6-minute Labor block, but I'll...
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:50
No, I'm sorry, it's...
Ben Small MP
0:59:52
[indecipherable]
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
0:59:55
Sorry, final question, which was interrupted. Are you saying that that element of Mr Bachelard's reporting, that video message, that video interpretation of your Bible reading and that text message interpretation of your Bible reading is false?
Bruce Hales
1:00:17
I would have no doubt in questioning the accuracy of Mr. Bachelard's reporting because he's been at it for nearly 20 years and I'm unfortunately and I'm afraid that one has to say that accuracy is not part of his Bible.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:00:43
Again, sorry, is that element of the reporting false? I'm happy for you to take it on notice if you want to consider that. But my question is—
Bruce Hales
1:00:54
I'll take that on, certainly.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:00:55
Thank you very much, Mr Small, it's your turn.
Ben Small MP
1:01:00
Thank you, Chair. Mr Hales, thank you for your time in appearing before the committee today. I just want to return to your role within the church and just tidy up a couple of elements there. Are you actually paid for your role within the church?
Bruce Hales
1:01:17
No, I'm not.
Ben Small MP
1:01:19
Okay. So what is your day job if you like?
Bruce Hales
1:01:24
Well, I'm retired now, but I was a tax advisor, and a company auditor for 50 years. And last year, I retired.
Ben Small MP
1:01:38
Oh, I'm sure you deserve a very happy retirement after 50 years on the tools, Mr. Hales.
Bruce Hales
1:01:44
I've got investments that have arisen out of my own private savings and I've been well looked after by my sons who are all in business successfully so that I don't need actually to be paid by the church to survive and lead a comfortable life.
Ben Small MP
1:02:09
Thank you that's useful content. On the matter of business people, and you've just mentioned your sons are successful and good on them, would it be natural for business people to take an interest in the government of Australia?
Bruce Hales
1:02:27
Well I think so that would be widely not in any way restricted to the Brethren community.
Ben Small MP
1:02:37
Quite right, in fact it's got nothing to do with their spirituality would you agree it's a little yeah yeah exactly shifts would you accept that Australians can disagree strongly on politics whilst still respecting each other?
Bruce Hales
1:02:54
Certainly.
Ben Small MP
1:02:57
Do you see any role for harassment, intimidation or other behaviour which would be illegal, in many senses, in our democracy?
Bruce Hales
1:03:06
Firstly, I very much object to any idea of harassment or intimidation. I don't agree with it, I don't support it and I utterly decry it.
Ben Small MP
1:03:23
Thank you, if I could just return to Mr Bachelard's reporting, I just want to give you an opportunity to expand a little. You mentioned that there's been articles for 20-odd years. What do you make of that journalism?
Bruce Hales
1:03:48
I don't really know, I gave him opportunity quite some years ago to look through the whole tenor and nature of the church organisation. He was invited even to the school. I remember that. I've never met him personally. But he seems to have some... given to him, To attack the church and its leadership and I'd have to say that it's somewhat of a mystery to me why why so can get quite so bitter and toxic at times.
Ben Small MP
1:04:38
Interesting. Have you ever met Mr. Albanese, the Prime Minister?
Bruce Hales
1:04:43
I have not.
Ben Small MP
1:04:45
Have you ever tried to meet Mr. Albanese?
Bruce Hales
1:04:49
We have written letters. The church has written letters to him more than once, but we've never been offered an interview.
Ben Small MP
1:05:01
And yet you're aware, obviously, he described describes your church as a cult in the 2025 election?
Bruce Hales
1:05:07
Yes, that term was first used by, I think, Mr Kevin Rudd, and of course, I do not agree with it. One iota. We are not a cult. We are Christians. We are a Christian, organisation, have been since the inception of the church I can't date 200 years ago, and from what I know of cults worldwide, I don't believe we bear any similitude to them at all.
Ben Small MP
1:05:46
So you've been publicly targeted as a church by two Labor prime ministers and in relation to your invitation to appear before this committee a media release was issued by the chair which demanded that you show up and fess up, as I quote. Do you feel that you've been treated fairly and impartially by this committee?
Bruce Hales
1:06:11
Look, I don't mind any robust conversational debate. I have to say the members of this committee today I think have treated me with respect and fairly. I can understand where they've got divergent views about political parties where you get, you know, you can get strong, very strong opinions either way. So I'm sympathetic with that, but I have to say yes, certainly I'm conscious that I've been targeted, but here I am today, I've turned up, I haven't objected, I'm here.
Ben Small MP
1:07:02
And I'm sure we're all very grateful for your time and contribution in that respect, Mr Hales. I take nothing away from that. Are you are you still concerned about, I guess, this idea that Australians might be targeted on the basis of their on the basis of their religious faith for participating in our democracy?
Bruce Hales
1:07:28
Well, I don't know what's going to go from here out, but I think I think this committee hearing should probably help to tone down the level of conversation and make it clear that there has been a fair bit of misinformation bandied around about my particular our particular church and its involvement in the election but as I've said numerous times I did not know At all, nor did I give directions or instructions as to some of the activities of the members in this 2025 election
Ben Small MP
1:08:20
No that's very clear from your written submissions and your extensive oral evidence today. Do you think that's any different to the Pope being held accountable for the actions of Catholics or indeed a bishop being held responsible for parishioners in some of in an Anglican church, like, is that any different?
Bruce Hales
1:08:45
No, I don't think it is
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:08:47
Last question, Mr Small.
Ben Small MP
1:08:50
Thank you very much, Chair. Finally, Mr. Hales, I guess, just to be absolutely clear, area. You agree that Australians of all political, sorry, all religious faiths should be able to participate in our democracy or choose not to, but that is a matter for them and nothing to do with their faith.
Bruce Hales
1:09:12
I think that's fair enough. I mean. To be fair, someone's faith in how highly they regard it and how deeply they are involved would be influential in how they choose to participate in any election, but I do think that the faith and participation is unrelated.
Ben Small MP
1:09:39
Thank you, Chair, and I think we've hit time with this witness.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:09:42
Senator Hodgins-May.

Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:09:43
Thank you. Mr. Hales, this week Turning Point USA which is a fairly prominent political organisation that targets young people to adopt a conservative ideology issued a statement in support of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church ahead of this hearing. Had you seen this statement before it was published?
Bruce Hales
1:10:01
Certainly not and I'm not sure that I've actually seen the statement.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:10:04
Have you heard whether any members of your church's leadership have ever met with spoken to Turning Point or Turning Point faith including you know potentially Charlie Kirk before death or the current chief executive, Erica Kirk?
Bruce Hales
1:10:18
No, not that I know of. I certainly remember the grievous assassination of Charlie Kirk, but I don't believe the Brethren had any contact with him whatsoever.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:10:32
I'm comfortable to table that statement too, if so, so you are aware of it, if you haven't already been notified. And what about with the Trump administration? Have you or any of your senior leadership team met with the Trump administration?
Bruce Hales
1:10:46
I understand there have been some members in the New York area have met Mr Trump briefly. I have never met him, nor have I ever directed anybody to attempt to secure an appointment or meeting with him.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:11:04
On notice, could you please try to get more information about who it was in that group in New York that met with. Mr Trump? Oh, Sorry, met with the Trump administration. Similarly, if you don't know now to take on notice, please, which senior members of your church trained in campaigning with Donald Trump's MAGA movement in the US it was reported in the age three church okay do you aware of that if the that training that occurred no.
Bruce Hales
1:11:30
No I'm not.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:11:31
Okay well if on notice you can make some inquiries to find that information for our committee that would be good. And just to be clear, the statement that we'll table that was made from Turning Point called for the US Department of State essentially to intervene in these proceedings today do you support the idea that a foreign government should intervene in an Australian parliamentary inquiry?
Ben Small MP
1:11:54
Point of order Chair. How can the witness possibly answer that question? He's here to account for himself and himself only.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:12:02
That's a question of him and
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:12:04
And he said he hasn't seen the statement.
Unidentified speaker
1:12:06
He said he hasn't seen the statement.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:12:07
I can read the statement. I can read the final sentence.
Ben Small MP
1:12:10
No, no, no. And we're over time.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:12:11
No, I'm not over time.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:12:13
Mr Small. Mr Small.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:12:13
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
Excuse you. Excuse you. It's not up... You're not the Chair
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:12:15
You're not the Chair, so please be quiet.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:12:18
The statement is about this inquiry. I think it's a valid question. And if Mr— Well,
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:12:26
Chair, on a point of order, how about the statement be made available to members of the committee so we can understand what it is?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:12:34
was just about to say, Senator Colbeck, if Mr. Hales can't answer it now, he is welcome to take it on notice given it has just been tabled and he hasn't read it. So you just interrupted me there. So the question was, do you think it's appropriate for a foreign government to interfere in an Australian parliamentary inquiry? It's a question about this inquiry and it's asking Mr Hales opinion. I've sat here for long enough to have questions asking about witnesses' opinions and if Mr Hales wants to understand the statement and understand the context, he can take the question on notice. Or answer it. He may wish to answer it.
Bruce Hales
1:13:20
Is there a question for me to answer?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:13:23
If you would like to.
Bruce Hales
1:13:24
I would have said it was rare for a foreign government to involve themselves in another country's inquiry such as this, but I had nothing to do if indeed that has occurred. I had no knowledge or participation in it.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:13:47
Thank you and and I'll note if you can look at that statement and say whether you think it's appropriate or not? Thank you. So I'm interested to know a bit more about how the church raises money. The Exclusive Brethren is registered as a charity, not a deductible gift recipient, which is correct, right? Correct?
Bruce Hales
1:14:10
I don't know that I understand your question, sorry.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:14:13
So the Exclusive Brethren are a registered charity. They're not a deductible gift recipient. Is that correct?
Bruce Hales
1:14:20
Well, the Exclusive Brethren as such is not a registered charity. The various trustees to which it owns property are registered as charitable. I'm afraid I think I'll have to take that one on notice.
Senator Steph Hodgins-May
1:14:40
Under the Government's proposed tax laws, discretionary trusts will be exempt from the proposed 30 minimum tax when making donations to registered charities, including organisations that aren't DGRs. Are you putting in place any strategies to potentially attract donations from this newly tax-advantaged pool of funds?
Bruce Hales
1:14:58
No, I'm certainly not aware of anything nor have I given any direction in regard to it. I have given substantially myself out of trusts that I have, which are fully documented and registered and of, which My accounts have been lodged with the Australian Government but apart from that I can't say anything further.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:15:25
Stop you there. You can put some questions on notice within seven days. Mr Neumann.

Shayne Neumann MP
1:15:33
Thank you Mr Hales. In your submission on the 5th of October this year you say you provide spiritual guidance to people. It's not my role to direct what members do politically. Yet this morning you said in your evidence in relation to a sermon that you believe members of Plymouth Brethren get that you... the get what you get, you get from the Lord. And I'm interested particularly in your sermon where you said you're happy again, smiling again.
Indeed, that's a phrase I heard many, many times during the election campaign by people wearing LNP shirts. And indeed, I saw that sort of phraseology used on billboards like let's make Australia happy, put Labor last and a billboard that was outside of an electronic billboard outside of the Raceview pre-poll on the 29th of April 25 in relation to the election.
So I'm just interested in your sermon because I've read the Bible from Genesis to Revelation and had many sermons in my Baptist church over many many years. I've never heard a preacher or pastor or priest ever talk about making Australia happy again. What did you really mean by that?
Bruce Hales
1:16:57
Well obviously you're not likely to find the reference to Australia in the Bible, are you?
Shayne Neumann MP
1:17:02
No, but no, not a nation. There's Israel and a lot of nations in the Bible mentioned.
Bruce Hales
1:17:07
And if we just refer to Acts 26, which is the third gospel sermon that we have recorded of Paul the Apostle, he uses that word happy. He was permitted to speak publicly, stretching out his hand in defence. He says, I count myself happy, King Agrippa so happy is a scriptural word used by the Apostle Paul in public. So you know, with all due respect, I don't know that there's a lot to defend, how to defend about it, Mr Neumann.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:17:52
Well, St Paul also says in Galatians chapter 5 verse 22 to 26, he talks about, you know, etc. But I've never heard of this idea that a nation should be happy. What did you really mean by that, which was then picked up by people wearing LNP shirts and put on billboards in terms of activity and political campaigning. Did you have any concept, any idea that that might happen?
Bruce Hales
1:18:17
No I did not. So what was your quote from Galatians?
Shayne Neumann MP
1:18:23
Galatians 5 verse 22 to 26 about the fruit of the spirit, joy.
Bruce Hales
1:18:27
Yeah that's very good. Love, joy, peace, long suffering, kindness, goodness, fidelity, meekness, self-control. Well, I just cannot at all recollect any input I had at all into what you claim to be the billboards and other advertising material during the election campaign. Whether someone showed me something, I don't know, I believe there was a photograph of the side of a truck. But I can't remember that expression being published.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:19:09
So you didn't have any discussions with any of your sons in relation to the activities that they then called to action for people in the Plymouth Brethren Church to man the and, know, the 1%, etc. It seems like a real gee -up, a call to arms. Discussions with any of your sons in relation to any of those matters whatsoever.
Bruce Hales
1:19:33
Now, the first... indication I had that my oldest son was out on the polling booths was a photograph in the paper and I was a bit surprised
Shayne Neumann MP
1:19:49
What did you do when you saw that photograph? Did you say, well look, what are you guys doing? You've completely misinterpreted what I had to say.
Bruce Hales
1:19:57
I said, what are you doing? What are you doing?
Shayne Neumann MP
1:20:01
What did you say to that when you said, what are you doing?
Bruce Hales
1:20:03
I can't remember. Listen, we've had no detailed discussions with my boys. I'm sorry. We very, very rarely discuss politics. It's not a big theme, Mr Neumann. I know you think it is, and I know, but I think most of your precious committee has got it wrong, and you're obviously hoping to uncover something that needs to be uncovered that's been hidden. But it's not the case.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:20:33
So just, you know, you used to call us our precious committee. That's a pretty pejorative sort of way to put it. But you know, with the ABS data, can I continue my questioning without being interrupted?
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:20:46
Do we actually want to have a debate?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:20:48
Senator McKenzie, please.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:20:51
Unbelievable.
Andrew Gee MP
1:20:51
ask McKenzie to leave because these are the rules that have been regular, they're burning up valuable committee time, and if Senator McKenzie cannot abide by the rules of this committee, she should leave.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:21:03
Senator McKenzie. Again, there are rules for the...
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:21:09
I'm sorry, Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:21:11
Are you?
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:21:12
Point of order, point of order. I'll ask the right, the right way then. I was going to say Senator Newman, that's promoting him. Mr Senator Neumann has been using language that is, I believe, disrespectful of the witness, who's of his own volition come here at a request of the committee calling it pejorative, and I would ask you Chair if you could examine the side of this witness to ascertain whether the witness was using pejorative language, but also Senators and MPs who have been using pejorative language in the course of this witness's evidence.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:21:51
Thank you. I'll review the Hansard when it becomes available. Please continue, Mr Neumann.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:21:57
Thank you. There's not been a Labor MP that Senator McKenzie hasn't interrupted and showed disrespect to today. Can I point that out.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:22:03
Please continue,
Shayne Neumann MP
1:22:05
So, Mr. Hales. For example, in my seat, there are, according to the ABS data, about 200 members of the Plymouth Brethren, and yet there were, there wasn't a polling booth or a pre -poll that there were at least 10 members of the Plymouth Brethren. I have well over 50 booths. Are you telling this committee that the fact that there were members of the P Plymouth Brethren on these polling booths saying, my margin will see, the Plymouth Brethren Church congregation and you had nothing to do whatsoever with that activity.
Bruce Hales
1:22:44
Absolutely. Individually, I speak for myself and collectively there was nothing ever said in any congregation to organise or promote or advance such activity.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:22:59
So you say in your submission to us that you wanted people to be fervent in prayer, you wanted Australian needs to be happy again, smiling again. In terms of the activity, as someone who preaches sermons, you want people to act on those sermons, do you not? It's not just about prayer, and it's not just about faith, because faith without works is nothing, is it not? That's what James says in the book of James, isn't He says it's dead actually, Dead, exactly. Faith without works is dead. You expect faith, you expect action, do you not, as a result of your sermons.
Bruce Hales
1:23:37
Not necessarily,, no.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:23:40
Well, you don't expect people to pray more, to do more, to act on behalf of your sermons? You don't expect them to do it at all? I wouldn't know a pastor or a priest that wouldn't expect their congregants to act on this sentence.
Ben Small MP
1:23:51
Mr Chair, again,. We're at eight minutes into a Labor questioning block and so far off the standing orders is not funny.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:23:59
There were two non-government members back to back Mr Small and everyone, including Mr Hales's, has gone over there a lot of times. So will Mr Neumann, if you've got two questions, and then I'll go to Ms Payne and Mr Gee and then we will close.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:24:17
So, Mr Harris, you would expect members of your congregations who are listening to your sermons to act on them, would you not?
Bruce Hales
1:24:27
Well, I would expect so, Mr Neumann, but sorry, our gospel preachings, for instance, our sermons, go out as an appeal. That is, it's the glad tidings we're preaching. I'm not...
Shayne Neumann MP
1:24:44
Okay, and And your sons have interpreted your appeal to an action to pull political action. And what you said in your sermons were put on electronic billboards, said by people in LNP shirts repeatedly. So your call to action, to use your expression, was acted on by your congregation. Isn't that correct?
Bruce Hales
1:25:10
I don't think that I was putting forward a plea for action. I don't believe that's the truth.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:25:17
You think it would be restricted to fervency and prayer, do you?
Bruce Hales
1:25:21
Yes, I do.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:25:24
And yet, you can't find a verse anywhere that calls people to action for national or corporate action. It's all about individuals. We've talked about individual happiness and you've quoted verses of the Bible. I've quoted verses of the Bible about individual happiness. You have called your congregation to political action. Isn't that the case?
Bruce Hales
1:25:46
No, it is not the case.
Shayne Neumann MP
1:25:48
So your sons were completely incorrect in their interpretation of your words?
Bruce Hales
1:25:54
I'm not going to answer for my sons because we've had very, very limited conversations as to the activities, and in fact, if we had any conversations in regard to the activities in the 2025 election. So I'm not going to apply
Shayne Neumann MP
1:26:08
my Question, Chair. My final question to Mr. Hales. Is the Liberal Party, in their review of the election, Thank you. Calls the Plymouth Brethren a support group. Have you done anything in respect of that review? Have you contacted the Liberal Party and said, oh, you've got it wrong. We were not a support group for you at all. The Liberal Party is completely erroneous in their review of the election. Have you done anything about that?
Bruce Hales
1:26:35
But why should I?
Shayne Neumann MP
1:26:37
Well, on your evidence today, they got it wrong.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:26:42
Mr Neumann, we will stop it there. Thank you very much. I'll go to Ms Payne then Mr G. And I Thank you for your indulgence, everybody, including the witness. There have been a few interruptions and a few people go over time and we will continue and try and wrap this up. Ms Payne.

Alicia Payne MP
1:26:58
Thank you, Mr Hales, for appearing before the committee this morning. Senior members of your church, including your son, were involved in a coordinated campaign of aggressive behaviour. Does that Payne concern you?
Bruce Hales
1:27:14
I don't know. I didn't know that they were involved. You're saying my sons, I've got four of them. I do not know what aggressive behaviour you are referring to.
Alicia Payne MP
1:27:24
It has been well documented in the media and your son's involvement and other senior members of your church. That's been well documented in the media. Are you not aware of that?
Bruce Hales
1:27:36
No, I'm not and I don't support aggressive behaviour.
Alicia Payne MP
1:27:41
When were you made aware of it.
Bruce Hales
1:27:45
You are asking me about something that I'm not even sure that I know what you're talking about, what was your name again?
Alicia Payne MP
1:27:52
I'm Alicia Payne, I'm the Member for Canberra.
Bruce Hales
1:27:55
No, I don't know what you are referring to. Sorry.
Alicia Payne MP
1:28:00
One particular article is from the Sydney Morning Herald on the 14th of September by Michael Bachelard and Sherryn Groch and it details, for example, that your son was involved in at least one chat group that was organising aggressive coordinated behaviour. We've had other senior members of the church say that they were involved.
Bruce Hales
1:28:26
With all due respect, I don't know anything about it. I'm not a member of any chat groups nor do I participate in chat groups. And I'm sorry you're asking the wrong person.
Alicia Payne MP
1:28:39
I didn't say that you were. I said that it's been reported that your son was and other senior members of your church have said that they were. You...
Bruce Hales
1:28:51
Sorry, but you are quoting their reporting as that's actual.
Alicia Payne MP
1:28:57
Lester Sharples has said that he was one of the people that organised this.
Bruce Hales
1:29:03
Well, I know of Lester Sharples, but I haven't spoken to him for probably two years.
Alicia Payne MP
1:29:08
Do you think that if members, senior members of your church are being reported as being involved in a coordinated campaign of aggressive behaviour around an election campaign that you should speak to them about that?
Bruce Hales
1:29:23
I know but you're asking a question that's hypothetical and somewhat nebulous.
Alicia Payne MP
1:29:28
Well I think that's just a matter for your opinion as a leader of the church if members, senior members of your church are being publicly reported to be coordinating aggressive behaviour around an election campaign, is that something you feel you should speak to them about?
Bruce Hales
1:29:46
Well I would speak about it if I knew about it, aware of the aggressive behaviour that you're purportedly drawing my attention to.
Alicia Payne MP
1:29:58
Well, it's been well reported and it's obviously in many submissions to this inquiry that...
Ben Small MP
1:30:04
Point of order, Chair.
Alicia Payne MP
1:30:05
...have been publicly...
Ben Small MP
1:30:06
almost badgering because we repeatedly asked the witness about what his views on Michael Bachelard's so-called journalism are and here we go again and again and again.
Alicia Payne MP
1:30:17
It's not views on journalism Mr Small, it's views on behaviour of members of his church that has been well documented and should he be concerned about that?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:30:26
Payne, it sounds like, and I might ask for clarification, Mr Hales, have you read or are you aware of the reporting on the 14th of September?
Bruce Hales
1:30:42
that what that?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:30:43
Tale, film, So the headline is Tail Film Heckle, inside the brethren's secret election influence plot with the far right.
Bruce Hales
1:30:52
No.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:30:53
You haven't read it?
Bruce Hales
1:30:55
No, I have not.
Alicia Payne MP
1:30:58
Okay. Are you, would you be disappointed that members of your church have been reportedly involved in aggressive behaviour, intimidation, stunts to embarrass...
Bruce Hales
1:31:13
Yes, if it's true, I certainly would certainly be concerned.
Alicia Payne MP
1:31:15
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Chair.
Unidentified speaker
1:31:17
Mr G?
Andrew Gee MP
1:31:19
Yes, thank you Mr Hay Hales. Mr Hales, I just wanted to check, have you been giving truthful evidence?
Ben Small MP
1:31:27
Hold up, hold up, hold up, hold up, Chair. This is beyond a disgraceful way to start the inquisition of a witness before a parliamentary committee. That is so far beyond the pale.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:31:41
What's wrong with Mr G? Mr G Mr G, I would remind you that the statement I gave at the opening which Mr Hales is bound by, the giving of false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be regarded as a contempt of parliament. So, it is taken that Mr Hales is answering truthfully and if there's evidence otherwise then he will be held to account for that. So I'd ask if you could continue with your questioning Mr G and not that G and not that first one is just taken unless proven otherwise.
Andrew Gee MP
1:32:16
The reason that I wanted to ask you that is because there is an article in today's Sydney Morning Herald, which refers to preaching. The article says that you did a Sunday church service two days after Mr Grimshaw gave evidence to this inquiry. And the words attributed to you in the article is these, it's not that we despise men in the world, capable men, but they haven't got the full story. They want you at any time to help them to fill the story out. We don't do it.. We didn't do it. We said, no, no, we're going to keep it, keep it to ourselves.
We've got our secrets. And then the article says, you go on to say, why should we, why should we tell the world everything we know? Why should you tell the world all about it? Keep it to yourself. Did you say those words, Mr. Hales?
Bruce Hales
1:33:17
Quite likely, but you see, the word mystery applies to the glad tidings and indeed it applies if anyone knows their Bible it applies to the church it's a. It's a mystery and that is what I would have meant by that why do we have to go out and explain every syllable that we state in the in the church conference.
Andrew Gee MP
1:33:47
Because reading that article Mr Hales and given your evidence today which was that you believe that church members would say and I quote what I get, I get from God. Do you think that those words could be interpreted as an exhortation not to give evidence to this committee or anyone else about what went on during the 2025 federal election campaign in terms of Brethren involvement?
Bruce Hales
1:34:15
No, not at all, I don't see any link with the two matters that you're referring to.
Andrew Gee MP
1:34:23
You've given evidence today, Mr. Hales, that... You expressed sympathy for anyone who may have felt intimidated by what went on in the 2025 election campaign. And I have to say that I personally was followed from booth to booth by members of the Plymouth Brethren. I had them crowd around me while standing on polling booths.
There was an incident where I had one filming me, and in fact, I had And also an incident where two young booth members reported to me that they felt so intimidated that they couldn't actually stand on the booth in question, when I went to check that out, there were multiple members of the Plymouth Bre Brethren on that booth. So I'm just wondering, given the fact that your evidence is that you do not support anyone being intimidated and that you don't agree with the harassment or intimidation of anyone and you've expressed what you have said is genuine sympathy, do you think you should apologise to anyone who felt intimidated by the actions of members of your church during the 2025 federal election campaign?
Bruce Hales
1:35:49
Well I think that anyone that's guilty of it individually should be prepared to apologise, yes.
Andrew Gee MP
1:35:56
But you've expressed sympathy about it in your evidence today as head of the church. As head of the church, do you think you should apologise? Do you think that would be the decent and Christian thing to do?
Bruce Hales
1:36:06
I haven't expressed sympathy or... intimidation or anything that is civil towards persons representing various political parties or members of the public. I'm sorry. I have no part in that whatsoever. Do not support it and, quite frankly, are against it.
Andrew Gee MP
1:36:32
But you've expressed your genuine sympathy. They were your words in your written statement that you gave. So don't you think you owe, as head of the church, anyone who felt So just let me finish please Mr Hales, don't you think you owe those people who felt intimidated an apology?
Bruce Hales
1:36:47
Not necessarily.
Andrew Gee MP
1:36:51
Alright, Mr Hales, would you agree with me Mr Hales that, and do you believe that religious organisations that enjoy charitable tax status should be engaged in partisan political campaigning?
Bruce Hales
1:37:14
don't know what to say exactly to that question because... I don't know what you mean behind the question, The participation of individual members of the church was their own responsibility and not what I would call church action.
Andrew Gee MP
1:37:34
Well, you've said that multiple times, Mr. Hales, and you've also said that the church and its members did not organise, promote or advance political campaigning. But given the evidence that you know exists in this committee and the mountain of media articles about this, what steps have you personally taken to ascertain the level of involvement of members of your church and members of your family in the 2025 federal election Campaign?
Bruce Hales
1:38:07
Very little because I read what comes to hand in the media articles but apart from what You might be thinking, because you've obviously been influenced by what I would call unsatisfactory or incompetent sources, I have not promoted antagonistic action in the public arena.
Andrew Gee MP
1:38:42
Given that entities enjoying charitable taxation status are not to be engaged in partisan political campaigning, given that what's at stake, I mean, it's been reported that 10 charities have assets worth hundreds of millions of dollars. Don't you think, given what's at stake? You personally should have investigated these allegations about the involvement of your church in the 2025 federal election Campaign.
Bruce Hales
1:39:18
Not necessarily, Mr G. No.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:39:22
Thanks, Mr G. Senator McKenzie with the final questions.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:39:28
Thank you. I don't want to detain the committee. I do apologise, Mr Hales, on behalf of the parliament, if you have felt persecuted through this hearing. I think there's a lot of Australians who aren't happy under the current government and you wouldn't have been the only public figure actually making public comments about that how people interpret sermons, whether they're from an Anglican pulpit, a mosque, Baptist lectern, is up to the individual and a decision between them and their faith. My question is, do you believe in a liberal democracy that citizens, irrespective of their faith, should be able to freely participate in federal elections?
Bruce Hales
1:40:19
Yes, as long as it's within the law.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:40:22
Do you think there's any difference? Have you seen CFMEU harassment or intimidation on any booths that you've had to vote in or walked past?
Bruce Hales
1:40:35
I've heard of it, but I'm…
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:40:38
There's lots of articles and maybe we should get the head of the CFMEU before the committee chair to actually look at the harassment and bullying that goes on at polling booths each and every election in each and every electorate across the country but in the interest of time I know we've got another witness to arrive. I'll put further questions on notice.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:41:03
Thank you, Senator McKenzie. And I think some of your answers there, Mr Hales, particularly in regards to as long as it's within the law, is probably why this committee has taken a lot of interest in the involvement of members of your church. I'd like to thank you very much, Mr Hales, for your attendance today and your indulgence to go over time a little bit. Members have seven have a seven days to put questions on notice to the secretariat through you.
So you'll be sent a copy of the transcript of your evidence to assist you with answering questions taken on notice today. I think you took a few on notice, and you'll have an opportunity to request corrections to transcription errors. Once you have received the transcript, you are asked to provide responses to any questions on notice within two weeks. Please forward these and any additional information that has been requested to the secretariat. Please note that responses to questions on notice will be published on the committee's website as submissions to the inquiry.
It now being .02, I'm just thinking, are 102, are we just happy to continue on, members? I know we had a break scheduled, but we'll continue on. Okay, so I won't suspend the inquiry. I thank you for attendance, Mr Hales, and we will now move to our next witness.
Bruce Hales
1:42:20
Alright, I thank you.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:42:36
My laptop is running low. I know the Labor members will be cheering, so I'm probably not going to make it for much longer so if I drop out I'm not being rude, I'm just out of battery.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:42:48
That's a shame, Senator McKenzie.
Senator Bridget McKenzie
1:42:50
I know. I hear you.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:42:54
I might suspend hearings until the next witness comes online.
[No speech]
1:42:59
[Hearing suspended: hold card "Short suspension, Committee Room 2R1", hold music, no speech]
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:44:34
We're broadcasting, great. I now welcome Mr Gareth Hales to give evidence today. For the Hansard Record, would you please state your full name and the capacity in which you appear before the committee?

Gareth Hales
1:44:46
My name is Gareth James Hales. I'm just here as an individual citizen.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:44:51
Thank you Mr Hales. Although the committee does not require you to give evidence under oath, I should advise you that this hearing is a legal proceeding of the parliament and therefore has the same standing as the proceedings of the respective houses. The giving of false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be regarded as a contempt of parliament. The evidence given today will be recorded by Hansard and attracts parliamentary privilege. I now invite you to make a brief opening statement of a few minutes before we proceed to discussion. If you've got one. Do you have an opening statement Mr. Hales? Yes I do. Off you go.
Gareth Hales
1:45:25
I've chaired members of the committee. I've accepted your invitation and am hearing voluntarily today. I was born and raised in Australia. I run businesses here, I employ people here. I've raised my own family here. I'm a father, a grandfather and an active member of my church and my broader community. Like millions of Australians I care deeply about this country and its future. As such I have my own views about how, it should be governed and I'm thankful to live in a, part of the world that affords its citizens a democratic right to participate in elections.
In 2025 I was deeply concerned about the direction the country was heading, particularly the, pressures on business and the people they employ. For the record I remain concerned about those very same things, the way this government treats businesses, particularly small to medium businesses, because the election result did not make those challenges disappear.
What I did as an individual was support a change of government and volunteer in the 2025 campaign. I've read this committee's terms of reference. I note that among the matters you're examining are any incidents of aggressive conduct, deliberate obstruction and intimidating behaviour towards voters, political participants, volunteers, and electoral officials during the 2025 federal election. At the outset, I want to be very clear that I do not condone own unlawful conduct of any kind by any person for any purpose. I did not witness any of this conduct during the campaign and had no involvement in or knowledge of organising any such conduct by others.
Like many Australians, my faith as a Christian is important to me. I am an active member of the Plymouth, Brethren Christian Church, although I hold no role in the church. Bruce Hales is my father. I have nothing to conceal or apologise for in any of that. That brings me to the journalist Michael Bachelard, whose reporting is featured in the allegations surrounding his inquiry and apparently accepted by the committee chair as true, despite denials issued prior to publication.
Committee members would know and understand from their own... campaigns, that their volunteers have come from all walks of life. Some have connections that overlap and others do not. I volunteer the chair's electorate of Bennelong alongside many others who simply shared a political preference. This committee should understand that campaigning alongside someone else does not mean adopting every opinion they have ever expressed. The committee chair is now taking a dangerous step using a group of volunteers' religious identity to associate them publicly with ideologies apparently held by others.
This committee should consider whether that risks discouraging participation in future democratic elections. What message does it send to campaign volunteers and to people of faith across this country if their beliefs can be used to imply wrongdoing by association. Michael Bachelard has waged a decades-long campaign of misinformation against the Brethren Church and has settled legal proceedings brought against him about his reporting. That context and history deserves scrutiny. Who, or at least I expect this committee, to bring an. Independent mind to Michael Bachelard's report in a similar way that brings an open mind to my comments?
As I've stated, I'm here voluntarily to assist. I will answer questions honestly to the extent of what I know, but I also will make this point plainly. Being a Christian, being a business owner and wanting a different government should not require an explanation or an apology. Thank you.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:49:29
Thank you Mr Hales. I'll go to the Deputy Chair.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:49:37
Thanks, Chair. Thanks, Mr Hales. Thanks for your opening statement. Do you believe that because you're a member of the Plymouth Brethren, you should be precluded from participating in the Australian electoral system?
Gareth Hales
1:49:54
No, I don't. I think I've got a perfect democratic right to participate or volunteer.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:50:03
Do you think that the process that this committee's undertaking is designed to discourage members of your church from, participating in the electoral system?
Gareth Hales
1:50:15
Yes, I do think that, and I think volunteering, there's nothing wrong with that. I think volunteering really strengthens social connections, brings people together across different backgrounds, generations and circumstances. Furthermore, it inspires people young and old to participate and can encourage colleagues, friends and family to demonstrate a spirit of friendship.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:50:42
Does your church in any way encourage or discourage participation within the electoral system and do you see that as being any different from any other Christian or any other faith for that matter, whether that be Muslim, Roman Catholic, Church of England, should that be a determining factor in your ability to participate?
Gareth Hales
1:51:13
No, I think to your question, Senator. It The P PBCC as such does not encourage us to participate, just like as you said, Muslims or Anglicans or Catholics or Jews, If they participate in an election, it's not the Church telling them to do that. They're doing that like we are, on our own individual right.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:51:37
you believe that you have the capacity to make up your own mind freely as to who might or might not support politically, and then act on that as a part of your participation in the faith?
Gareth Hales
1:51:58
Absolutely. As long as we don't do anything illegal, don't do anything unlawful, don't do anything wrong. I can't see the issue with that.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:52:15
Did you observe any examples of aggression towards members of your community during your participation in the campaign?
Gareth Hales
1:52:32
I can only speak to what I know and what I saw and what I did, but I didn't actually see any harassment or intimidation. I did hear reports of it, but I But I didn't witness it myself.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:52:46
Okay, so did you observe during your participation on polling booths in Bennelong? To any acts of aggressive behaviour?
Gareth Hales
1:52:59
No, I myself didn't. But I would say if I saw poor behaviour or bad behaviour, I would have called it out and put it right.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:53:17
So, your experience as a participant, as the campaign in 2025 in Bennelong was largely one that observed... well how would you characterise the behaviour you saw on the polling booths, your interactions and the discussions with people on the polling booths?
Gareth Hales
1:53:43
I thought it was fairly friendly, in the main. I had very little personal involvement in the election. I did two one -hour sessions of door -knocking, and chats with the Notelands. Then I did three booth visits. One was at Eastwood Baptist Church. I had a Liberal t-shirt on. I was handing out free poll leaflets, having just friendly chats to the locals there. I then went on to Top Ryde and Bradfield for half an hour. I did one Parramatta visit to a booth for 45 minutes. A little bit more heated there but I didn't see anything real aggressive, to be honest
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:54:22
So the characterisation of the activities of members of your church in the election campaign being aggressive and overbearing, How would you describe those?
Gareth Hales
1:54:43
well I don't like aggression, I don like harassment. I disagree with poor behaviour. As I said earlier, if it was brought to my notice, I would have followed that individual up and told them to write a letter apology or put it right.
Senator Richard Colbeck (Deputy Chair)
1:55:01
Okay, thanks Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:55:03
Thank you Deputy Chair, Ms Campbell.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:55:05
Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Mr Hales, for appearing before the committee today. Well, I don't Hales, in his questioning, Mr Small likened Bruce Hales to the Pope of the Catholic Church on two occasions and Bruce Hales agreed with that likening. So Mr Bruce Hales is both the Pope equivalent of the Brethren and your Father, that's correct?
Gareth Hales
1:55:32
He wasn't exactly the Pope but he's the leader of our church globally.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:55:38
Okay. And Mr Hales, sorry, sorry.
Ben Small MP
1:55:38
And to be fair, Chair, just on a point of order, that's some verballing and a complete misinterpretation of the evidence on Hansard.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
1:55:46
Yes, Mr Small. There was an answer. Let's keep on going on.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:55:51
Sorry, Mr Small, I was relying on what you've said. My apologies. Mr Hales, can you tell us what global media stream or GSM is?
Gareth Hales
1:56:04
not sure what you're referring to there, unless it's when we have meetings on Zoom and it's global meetings, maybe it applies to that.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:56:14
Sorry, so a global media stream or GSM, sorry, GMS.
Gareth Hales
1:56:23
Well during COVID we had a lot of meetings on Zoom. So it was probably that streaming. Mostly we go physically to our meetings, but I know sometimes when we have, like, we had some global meetings in Westfield and New York about a month ago, and that was globally streamed, so other people could watch it and interact interactive. Yes, and your father, if required.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:56:44
Yes, and your father gave evidence previously indicating that the services were streamed in a global way. So, yes. On the 20th of April, your father gave a sermon, it was published on GMS; do you recall that sermon?
Gareth Hales
1:57:04
No, not that particular one. Which one are you referring to?
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:57:09
I'm happy to refresh your memory. In it Bruce Hales said Australia needs to be happy again, smiling again and he talked about being fervent in their prayers and in his evidence he said that in that context he was referring to dissatisfaction with government.
Gareth Hales
1:57:33
I think I think the happy thing was make Australia happy again. Might have been make Australia smile again. I know he likes a song that's called when you're smiling the whole world smiles with you. I've actually played it on the piano.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:57:47
Yeah, boring at times. No for clarity this week, sorry Mr Hales.
Gareth Hales
1:57:55
I was just going to say, but I just can't see what's wrong with actually saying make Australia smile again or make Australia happy again. I think that's a good...
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:58:05
My apologies, Mr. House, I wasn't saying that at all. I was, just for clarity though, in terms of the song that you've just quoted, it didn't say those words. It said, needs to be happy again, smiling again. So in terms of that, you've obviously, you now recall that GMS recording of your father's sermon. How did you interpret that message?
Gareth Hales
1:58:30
Exactly as you said it. Just Australia needs to be happy again. Needs to smile again.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:58:37
Okay, and
Gareth Hales
1:58:38
I mean, yeah.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:58:39
and thank you for that. And did you appear in a video with your brothers or write any messages or any written words at all in any format or communication with an interpretation of that message?
Gareth Hales
1:58:56
No, I didn't. I got on some WhatsApp, I got on on some calls, some video calls.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:59:02
Yep.
Gareth Hales
1:59:02
And I don't know that I repeated, I don't think I repeated that message.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
1:59:07
Yeah, okay I'm just going to read an excerpt and this is in quotes how awesome was it to hear that recording on GMS we should all be freshly charged and motivated to give this all we've got. We are well and truly into the game and it's game on now. As we are reminded, as we were reminded we need to focus on what we can control. Forget the media, pray and take action instead. Make sure our booths are manned and volunteers fired up each day to dominate the play. It's all in the extra one percent. We don't want wanted any resource wasted.
Keep up the ground game with an undecided bubble as large was what our own polling is showing we must keep up pressing the flesh shaking hands and talking to voters and the streets the Lord can do what we can't stay focused and make sure we don't leave any gas in the tank appreciate everyone's tireless efforts and commitment so far it's inspirational thank you and keep it up and then there's two emojis of punching boxing gloves did Did you say that?
Gareth Hales
2:00:07
That's a lot of words to take in.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:00:09
Did you say some of that? Sorry, that's, that's,
Gareth Hales
2:00:12
think that I don't think that was my words, but I would have listened to people speak about their experiences. I might have offered a little bit of encouragement, but in no way did I direct them, or control
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:00:26
them, or manage them. So you didn't say those words? Sorry, Mr Howser, are you saying you didn't say those words?
Gareth Hales
2:00:31
I don't believe I said those words.
Unidentified speaker
2:00:32
Did you write those words?
Gareth Hales
2:00:34
I'd have to check the source of your document. I can take that on notice if you want.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:00:42
That would be wonderful. So, but essentially what that does is it ties that GMS recording of the sermon to the campaign that was being run on the ground. Did you interpret the sermon from your father on the 20th of April in 2025. Did you link that to the campaigning that you did on the ground that you've talked about?
Gareth Hales
2:01:13
No, no, I didn't link that at all.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:01:15
Okay. So, Mr Hales said that our sermons go out as an appeal and made it clear that those sermons were very rarely misinterpreted and, in terms of the messages provided, he said it's clear. So I did want to ask I did want to ask if the sermon was given on the 20th and then quite close to that, that message was put out, which you cannot confirm that you did not say read or write. If, yourself. If those two things happened in close proximity to each other, and the message has a direct link to the sermon, how would that not be an appeal to go out and campaign?
Gareth Hales
2:02:10
No, the Bible readings you're talking about in the sermons. We read about Old Testament, New Testament. We talk about Abraham, Moses, David. We talk about Paul. We talk about the Gospels, John and Mark and Matthew.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:02:24
So, um, Mr Hales
Gareth Hales
2:02:26
We don't talk about politics. We don't actually encourage people to get out there and campaign. That is not the church, church's job,
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:02:35
So, Mr Hales,
Gareth Hales
2:02:36
It's not Mr Hales' job to do that.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:02:38
Yeah, so Mr. Bruce Hales talked about the sermons being an appeal to the membership, and he said that those were very rarely misinterpreted. If once you confirm whether or not this link between the GMS recording and very much a call to action more broadly to the membership did happen in that way, did you disobey Mr Hales or did you misinterpret his message? Or in fact, did you interpret the message in that way?
Gareth Hales
2:03:12
Every sermon has an appeal. The appeal is generally be attracted to Christ, come be a follower of Christ, obey his word. Be governed by his word.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:03:24
And so
Gareth Hales
2:03:25
There is no appeal there linked to the campaigning. I just think that's been taken out of context, to be honest.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:03:32
In that message, you say, game on and make sure our booths are manned. What do you think those phrases mean?
Gareth Hales
2:03:41
Game on, I would assume. It just means to encourage people to get out in their democratic right, do what they want to do, but once again, I don't think that is my words.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:03:54
okay, and did you receive I understand that you're saying that you don't believe those words, but you can't confirm that and you haven't confirmed that for the committee, unless you would like to confirm that those aren't your words?
Gareth Hales
2:04:10
I have to look at the source documents to actually verify they are my words. Okay.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:04:16
Did you receive any feedback about either that message or any other message that was similar in nature to it?
Gareth Hales
2:04:26
No, I didn't receive any feedback, no.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:04:29
And for clarity, in terms of Bruce Hales's sermons more broadly, you never consider taking any action out of them?
Gareth Hales
2:04:41
No, definitely, definitely not from a political point of view.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:04:43
No, no, no, for clarity, for clarity, sorry, Mr. Hales, I should have been clearer. In terms of sermons that you listen to from your father, the most senior member globally in the church, do you, once a sermon is given, do you think that you should take any action or do anything as a result of it?
Gareth Hales
2:05:07
from a spiritual point of view or a Christian point of view
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:05:10
From any point of action
Gareth Hales
2:05:12
to believe it in the will of God or the word of God or to follow Christ or follow the land where so ever it goes I mean that's I am just using scriptures now, but we have subjects like the Good and Acceptable Perfect Will of God. That would make me want to be governed by the Will of God.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:05:33
So, I guess my question is, when you listen to those studies that you talk about, do you think that you should do anything after them, or do you think they should just lie and that they should just lie as they are and members should therefore not do anything as a result of that sermon or that preaching?
Gareth Hales
2:05:57
I think they should just lie as they are.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:05:59
Okay, so you think that sermons should have no consequence?
Gareth Hales
2:06:07
Same, sermons shouldn't have a consequence. I'm saying the sermon consequence should be that we're more committed to our faith, and we become more spiritual, and we do the right thing.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:06:17
Do the right thing.
Gareth Hales
2:06:18
There's no there's no connection with that and the political campaign that you're talking about today, the 2025 political campaign.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:06:25
For clarity you will come back to us as you've kindly agreed in terms of that message and clarifying whether that was you or not. Last question is good. Thank you. Mr Hales, earlier you said as long as we don't do anything illegal or unlawful. In terms of that, do you believe that the Plymouth Brethren should be precluded be precluded from the electoral laws of this country?
Gareth Hales
2:06:59
Just unpack that a little bit more, what do you mean?
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:07:02
Do you believe that the Plymouth Brethren, as with any other organisation at all, should be precluded from following the electoral laws of this country?
Gareth Hales
2:07:14
We absolutely believe in the electoral laws and, just so you know, we've got full respect for government. Government is of God, we refer to it as the head of gold, which is in scripture. It's a territory of work, and I believe government should represent trust and cooperation and build constructive relationships between businesses, communities, and government representatives.
Julie-Ann Campbell MP
2:07:37
Thank you very much, Mr Hales. I appreciate your time.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:07:40
Thank you, Ms Campbell. Ms Ryan, please.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:07:43
Well, thank you, Mr House, thanks for coming today. Your father told us that members of the church looked to him for guidance on doctrine. Do you believe that your father is a direct messenger from God?
Gareth Hales
2:07:59
I believe he represents the spirit of Christ and the spirit of Christianity, and we talk about Christ as a good shepherd, the great shepherd, the chief shepherd, and I would say him and his father, and some of these other men that have led the recovery as we talk about it have led the church. They've guided us and guarded us and shepherded us. Yes.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:08:21
And is it your expectation that you or one of your brothers will succeed your father as head of the church?
Gareth Hales
2:08:29
If you have to ask my brothers, I don't think that's my job. Certainly not me.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:08:34
thank you. I'm interested in your involvement in the campaign. I don't think any member of this of this committee thinks that people of faith don't have the right to be part of democracy in Australia, but the concern clearly is the fact that the involvement of the church and what appeared to be a mass mobilisation of PBCC members was more consistent with an institutional operation than one that was sort of individual. Just to that, do you own a business called Sante Global?
Gareth Hales
2:09:09
Yes, sir.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:09:11
And did Sante Global book a room for a meeting at the Ryde-Parramatta Golf Club in Sydney on the 1st of April 2025?
Gareth Hales
2:09:20
Yes, we did.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:09:22
Are you able to tell me who attended that meeting and what was discussed at it?
Gareth Hales
2:09:29
Well, it would have been Sante businesses and Sante suppliers, Sante contractors.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:09:37
Okay, so Mr Lester Sharples, he's someone who is known to you?
Gareth Hales
2:09:43
I don't know him very well, but I have heard of him.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:09:45
Okay. Well, he's a senior member of the church, as I believe are you. Can I just check? You are a member of the church's Global Advisory Panel?
Gareth Hales
2:09:55
No, I'm not on the global advisory panel, no, that's not my role.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:09:59
OK. Mr Sharples, who is a senior member of the church, has said in the public space that he attended this meeting and that you were in attendance at it.
Gareth Hales
2:10:13
now I had two meetings with him with business I hear it at our premises and we spoke briefly about the campaign, but I haven't heard or seen from him since.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:10:24
Can you confirm that on that occasion, on the 1st of April 2025, members of the Brethren Church discussed the employment of right-wing activists. I'm going to give you some names. Morgan C Jonas, Chris De Bruyne, Laurence McIntyre, Harrison McLean, Matt Trihey or Joel Davis? Any or all of those to disrupt campaign activities during the 2025 federal election?
Gareth Hales
2:10:55
The only two names I know is Morgan and Chris.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:11:00
Do you agree that the members of your church, you being one of them, employed those gentlemen to disrupt electoral campaign activities during the last federal election?
Gareth Hales
2:11:11
Certainly not. I never discussed that with either Morgan or Chris.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:11:15
I'm not asking you if you discuss them, Mr Hales, I'm asking if you or other members of the group that met in Sydney on the first of April 2025 discussed the prospect of employing these activists and paying them to disrupt campaign activities, including activities by the Prime Minister of Australia, during the 2025 Federal election.
Gareth Hales
2:11:41
I can't talk for other members of the group, but Sante most definitely did not employ Morgan or Chris. Furthermore, I would not support, as you said, right-wing activists to harass or intimidate the Prime Minister or any government official.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:12:00
Okay. Mr Hales, have you had any dealings with a gentleman by the name of Sam Jackson-Hope?
Gareth Hales
2:12:09
I met Sam Jackson-Hope once on the campaign trail. I think it was up at Carlingford, probably spoke to him for three minutes just a quick update on how the general election was going.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:12:22
You understand that he was a representative and a member of the team for Mr Peter Dutton, the leader of the opposition at the last federal election?
Gareth Hales
2:12:31
Yes, I'm aware that he's on Peter Dutton's team.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:12:34
And was that the capacity in which you met with him as a member of the team for the leader of the opposition at the last federal election?
Gareth Hales
2:12:45
No, I just met him as a private citizen.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:12:49
So what were the circumstances of that meeting Mr Hales?
Gareth Hales
2:12:55
It was up at a petrol station and Mr Dutton was there, and a whole team and a whole bunch of people round him. He was giving a speech about fuel.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:13:09
You were just there in your capacity as a private citizen, not as a senior member of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church?
Gareth Hales
2:13:17
I definitely was a private citizen
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:13:19
citizen. The Leader of the Opposition just happened to have a member of his team just happened to have a conversation with you at that point? Have you ever had a personal conversation yourself with Peter Dutton?
Gareth Hales
2:13:32
I I met Peter Dutton at that same time, Spoke to him passing. He had a lot of people around him. He had a very busy agenda. So, no, he didn't speak to him for long.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:13:42
Okay. Mr Hales, it's alleged that your brother Dean told business owners within the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church, and I quote, if the libs get in, you will more than make up for any lost profit associated with members of the church's involvement with the in the in the election Did you give any of your staff paid time off to campaign during the campaign?
Gareth Hales
2:14:04
No, definitely not. We were busy at that time in business, so I didn't want any of my staff to have time off to campaign. If they did, it would have been in their private time.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:14:18
And just finally, your father, who is the elect vessel, is the head of your church. Would you agree that people sometimes refer to him as the elect vessel?
Gareth Hales
2:14:30
No, we only refer to the elect vessel in Paul, because it's scripture, but Dad doesn't like the term elect vessel and no, we never, I've never used it as he's saying no.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:14:41
Okay, do you have to ask him for permission to, would you have to ask him for permission to, for example, participate in electoral activities as you did in 2025? Would you expect that that would be something that he would expect to be made aware of, that sort of activity?
Gareth Hales
2:15:00
No, not at all. I wouldn't have to ask any permission off him.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:15:04
So as a member of the
Gareth Hales
2:15:05
got my own father, I've got my own household, I've got my own family. I don't have to. Check off everything with him. Absolutely not.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:15:13
Great. And so just to be clear, because I know that many members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church globally are watching this testimony today, members of the church are free to do what they want and act as they like when it comes to involvement in federal election campaigns in Australia?
Gareth Hales
2:15:32
Well, yes, we've all got a democratic right to participate in an election. Faith and participation are not related.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:15:42
Did you vote in the last federal election, Mr House?
Gareth Hales
2:15:47
No I didn't.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:15:48
Can I ask you why that would be if you cared so much about the proceedings that you decided to volunteer on multiple occasions?
Gareth Hales
2:15:56
Sure. I believe I have a religious duty to abstain from voting but that doesn't remove my interest in the country's future and direction.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:16:06
What do you think would happen if everybody abstained from voting Mr House?
Gareth Hales
2:16:09
It wouldn't be an election, would it?
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:16:14
Which might put paid to the democratic process don't you think?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:16:21
Good well, Last question.
Dr Monique Ryan MP
2:16:24
One last One last question Mr Hales, why is it that members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church don't take the oath when they appear in front of parliamentary committees?
Gareth Hales
2:16:35
I haven't got my Bible in front of me but there's many scriptures that we're not to swear on the Bible.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:16:41
Dr Ryan, it's not a requirement for our members to give an oath, so thank you. Senator Mulholland.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:16:52
Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Mr Hales, for accepting the committee's invitation to appear today. In your opening statement, you said that you don't condone unlawful or aggressive conduct and you didn't witness any unlawful or aggressive conduct on the polling booths and the pre polling booths that you attended during the campaign. What about in chat groups to do with the election that you remember of? Did you see any unlawful and aggressive conduct related to the election in any chat groups that you were involved in?
Gareth Hales
2:17:29
I definitely, definitely not. Like I said, if I saw poor behaviour or bad behaviour or aggression or harassment, I would call it straight out. That's not me and I don't agree with that behaviour. I don't believe it belongs in election processes.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:17:46
In response to Ms Campbell's questioning you said that you were active in some WhatsApp chats. Were you active in a WhatsApp chat called Queensland Albo Events?
Gareth Hales
2:18:03
I don't believe so. I was invited to a number of groups but I didn't participate in them and I remember being dropped off some group chats about two weeks afterwards.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:18:14
Two weeks after the election, or two weeks after you were added?
Gareth Hales
2:18:18
I think two weeks after I was added.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:18:22
There are media reports that you were a member of the Queensland Albo Events WhatsApp group and that you were added by Lloyd Hutchinson. Are you aware of that?
Gareth Hales
2:18:36
No, I'm not.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:18:39
But you do use the WhatsApp chats function and that app you've said that you are
Gareth Hales
2:18:48
chats for business, yeah.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:18:49
and you were added to a chat called Queensland Albo but you're saying that you're going to wear it. That's your evidence.
Gareth Hales
2:18:59
I don't recall that.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:19:02
Documents presented to the Sydney Morning Herald, including screenshots of the Queensland Albo events, show that you were added to that chat on the 18th of March 2025, and that chat group was used to tail and heckle and intimidate politicians and candidates and and people including the Prime Minister. Would you consider that to be unlawful or aggressive behaviour?
Gareth Hales
2:19:37
I wouldn't say the tale of Heckle is unlawful, but I wouldn't agree with it and I wouldn't participate in it. I'd just like to ask the actual, who actually wrote that article, was that Michael Bachelard? Anything he says, I would take with a. With a complete pinch. He's just been attacking our church for 20 years, but he doesn't know you make it up.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:20:07
In this example, it's not his allegations, it's actually screenshots provided to him of this chat. Those are provided as pieces of evidence in an article, so it isn't just someone's say so. As a journalist, it is evidence that's been presented in that story. And I just want to come back to your point that you say that you don't have it, so you don't see it as being unlawful, the behaviour of hailing and harassing people. I mean, that's behaviour that is tantamount to stalking, repeated. Patterns of behaviour surveilling and harassing people to cause fear and intimidation, that's town scimitar stack to stalking behaviour. You don't think that's an issue?
Gareth Hales
2:20:50
No, no, I don't agree with it at all. I've never participated in it. I don't agree with it I don't and I don't support it.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:20:58
Right. So in these chat groups, there is also discussion around engaging with known far right personalities who attend white supremacy and neo-Nazis events. And in this chat that you were a member of the ALBO events there is a chat on the 12th of April where one individual who was engaged to harass politicians asked, quote, do you need bank details for payment or do you guys work on a cash system?
Gareth Hales
2:21:35
So... No, I had no contact. I've had no contact with neo-Nazis and I completely reject their views.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:21:43
In this same article from the 14th of September, Mr Hales, four sources have said that you were at a secret meeting between members of the Brethren Church and far-right activists and a golf course in Sydney, in the first days of the election to talk about this plot to pale, harass, stork, surveil politicians and candidates, including the Prime Minister. Were you at that meeting?
Gareth Hales
2:22:15
No, I haven't had meetings with far-right protesters.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:22:18
You were not at a meeting...
Gareth Hales
2:22:19
So I had
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:22:22
You were not at a meeting a Sydney golf course in the election to talk about behaviour that included and, tactics that included, stalking and following and using various apps to surveil the Prime Minister and his location to then send people who are being paid for to go and interrupt and harass the Prime Minister and candidates. You were not at such a meeting at a golf course in Sydney in the first week of the game?
Gareth Hales
2:22:51
No, the only meetings I've had at the golf course are business meetings, business related, nothing to do with stalking, following, all these other things that you're speaking about
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:23:03
The four sources in this article have placed you at that meeting.
Gareth Hales
2:23:13
No, I would not have to. I could check the question on notice, but no.
Senator Corinne Mulholland
2:23:20
If you If you could take the question on notice, that would be appreciated. Just so there's no avoidance of any doubt because there is evidence on the record from four sources who have said that you were there. You, back to you.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:23:37
Thank you. We don't have Senator Hodgins -May, so I'll go to Mr Small. For The
Ben Small MP
2:23:43
Thanks very much, Chair. And thanks for your time today, Mr. Hales. I could just run through a couple to things, I guess it's fair to say obviously through Sante Global that you're a businessman, that's your main occupation.
Gareth Hales
2:23:59
Yeah, that's correct. He's a businessman. Sorry, go on.
Ben Small MP
2:24:06
Is that what led you to sort of get involved in a personal capacity in the 2025 campaign?
Gareth Hales
2:24:14
Yeah, well, I was a concerned businessman and I belong to a lot of business groups, and that's church and non -church, mainly non -church. And obviously as a businessman, it gives me an opportunity to help provide for other families. We talk about the family, the backbone of society, dads and mums working through life, paying off mortgages, getting the family through. Obviously business teaches you whether the ups and downs of life, teaches you patience and wisdom and self -control. But yeah, I was concerned, in what direction the country was going and the government was going. But At no point did I direct or manage or coordinate a campaign drive.
Ben Small MP
2:24:59
Do you remain concerned about the direction of Australia?
Gareth Hales
2:25:04
Yes I certainly do. I can say as an Australian, I care deeply about Australia. Australia gives opportunities to help persons that are struggling. It helps to raise the next generation, teaching children courage and respect and perseverance. But what Australia means to me, and this is why I'm deeply passionate about it, is that it means friendship. It's mateship,. It's community. It's genuine friends that have your back through the good times and the bad times. And what I love about Australia is its democratic freedom, its natural beauty. Its life, and it's storytelling.
Ben Small MP
2:25:51
Very hard to disagree with Mr Hales. Do you believe that Australians should have the same rights to participate in our democracy regardless of their religious beliefs?
Gareth Hales
2:26:02
Absolutely. As I said before, faith and politics is completely separate and different.
Ben Small MP
2:26:11
are you aware that the Electoral Act allows Australians to claim a religious belief as an exemption from the requirement to vote?
Gareth Hales
2:26:21
[unclear] I'm aware of that.
Ben Small MP
2:26:24
And just to be really clear, therefore, that your conduct in response to Dr. Ryan's question was absolutely lawful and that you were making use of an existing provision. Of the law in Australia.
Gareth Hales
2:26:40
Sure, that's noted. Thank you.
Ben Small MP
2:26:42
No, no, thank you very much. I do want to turn as I did with Mr Bruce Hales previously to the journalism from Mr Michael Bachelard. And indeed the Sydney Morning Herald articles that Labor MPs have spent all morning quoting from. What do you know about Mr Michael Bachelard? And what has your experience with his journalism been?
Gareth Hales
2:27:11
I just know, I think he met the Brethren in 07 from memory, I think we invited him to our schools and he showed him around, just tried to open up and be honest about everything, but since then he's had a deep, deep hatred against us. He's been poisonous, and he's written articles for nearly 20 years attacking my father, attacking me, personally, attacking the church, attacking our businesses.
That It's almost seems to be his full time occupation is to try and take down the PBCC. So he's full of lies, he's full of bias, he's full of prejudice. He doesn't tell the truth. And I would say openly, if Mr. Bachelard is listening to these will come and down, come and come around and come down and sit with us and let's chat rather than just attack us through the brakes. It was a chance to tell the real story.
Ben Small MP
2:28:05
And it sounds a lot like the invitation that the PBCC have extended to the Prime Minister. Have you ever met Mr. Albanese? Mr. House?
Gareth Hales
2:28:14
No, I haven't. But we have written letters to him to come and sit down with us and have a chat. We understand he's under pressure as a global leader. As I said, we respect government, hit a goal, but now we'd love to sit down with him and he opened up our families, our businesses, our culture, come and talk to us and see what we're really liking in real life.
Ben Small MP
2:28:38
When two Labor Prime Ministers have described your church as a cult and subjected you to sort of public persecution and indeed the media released from this committee inviting your attendance today required you to, and I quote, show up and fess up. Did you expect a fair and impartial treatment from the committee today?
Gareth Hales
2:28:59
Yeah, no, I thought it was a bit rough. As you said, Mr R rada, Mr Branders and Colt, they haven't, yeah, they haven't ever sat down with us and shouted to us or talked to us and then they show up and fess up. There's nothing to confess. I'm here openly to talk about any subject, any inquiry. And yeah, I do think it's a little bit of a beat up on the church, to be honest.
Ben Small MP
2:29:25
I appreciate your direct answers, thank you Mr House.
Gareth Hales
2:29:27
Obviously nothing against Catholics or Anglicans or other faiths, but I'm sure other members of faith would have gone out and participated in the election as they have a democratic right, but I haven't seen any newspaper articles about their activity.
Ben Small MP
2:29:42
Alright, thank you Chair.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:29:45
Thank you, Mr Neumann.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:29:48
Most of my questions on Sante Global Proprietary Limited have been asked by other members, but you're the CEO, aren't you, of Sante Global, and your evidence today that no payments were made to activists or political parties from that company in relation to campaign disruptions. Is that your evidence?
Gareth Hales
2:30:17
That's correct. No payments, no funds.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:30:20
And so the media reports that talk about Sante Global being a client, they're incorrect, are they?
Gareth Hales
2:30:29
They're incorrect.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:30:31
Okay. So why did you resign as a director of that company on the 30th of September 2025?
Gareth Hales
2:30:41
I resigned from what company?
Shayne Neumann MP
2:30:43
As a director of the company.
Gareth Hales
2:30:47
I'm not aware that I resigned, but just nicely, Mr Neumann, what relevance does that have with the 2025?
Shayne Neumann MP
2:30:54
Well, the allegations are that that company was involved in funding a far-right group, so it has relevance.
Gareth Hales
2:31:02
No, that's not true. We never funded. I completely reject that.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:31:04
right, can I ask a question? Your evidence today is that you're as a private citizen choosing not to vote, that's your right, lawfully, choose not to vote, but you wish to influence the outcome of the election. So,
Shayne Neumann MP
2:31:20
did you influence or ask any persons to hand out how-to-vote cards at pre-poll or election day?
Gareth Hales
2:31:28
No, I didn't. I had a very, very light touch on the election.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:31:33
You went to a number of different polling booths, you said, in a number of different seats didn't you?
Gareth Hales
2:31:39
Yeah ,avi went to three polling booths, plus Parramatta, so that was four polling booths in total.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:31:47
Well, how did that happen? For a bloke that hasn't participated, and I think your evidence would be that you don't normally participate, in political activities, you don't even vote. How is it that you decided to or went to three different polling booths in a number of different seats, how did that happen?
Gareth Hales
2:32:03
Well, the first one I went to was Eastward. That's near an oval where I run, it's called ELS Oval. I drove past and there weren't many boys in blue. So I thought I better get out there and support. So I put a liberal t shirt and went there for half an hour and gave out pre-poll cards.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:32:22
Sorry, just one second, Mr Neumann. Earlier in your evidence, Mr. Hales, you said that you encouraged you sort of were part of a video message to encourage people to participate in the election. That's at odds with the evidence you've just given there to Mr Neumann. Could you clarify, did you encourage people to participate or did you not?
Gareth Hales
2:32:45
What I said was, I didn't direct or coordinate, but if I was on a call, of course, every time I'm on a leader is expected to encourage, inspire, if at all possible.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:32:58
I ask the question spit Mr. Hales, did you ask anyone to do anything?
Gareth Hales
2:33:04
No, I didn't.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:33:06
You just said you did.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:33:07
I can't understand. You didn't, you encouraged, can you clarify that? So did you ask anyone on the phone or in person or by email or anything to participate in any activities of this campaign as a private individual, did you?
Gareth Hales
2:33:23
No, it was just a general talk on the campaign or on election. People were sharing stories. But no, I wasn't directing people to carry
Shayne Neumann MP
2:33:32
out certain things That's not what I asked, Mr. Hales. I asked whether you asked anyone to participate. You directed anyone.
Ben Small MP
2:33:40
Just to assist, Chair, because I think I can understand the confusion here, there's a difference between participating broadly in the election and the requirement to direct for handing out that vote.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:33:53
Mr Small, we'll let Mr Hales ask the question. The question wasn't of you, the question was of Mr Hales. So Mr Hales, if you want to answer Mr Neumann's questions.
Gareth Hales
2:34:01
Well, just the word encourage, it was people that campaigning. Yeah sure, I'll probably just encourage them to keep doing what they were doing.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:34:11
So what do you mean by that? So you encouraged people? How many people are you talking about here?
Gareth Hales
2:34:17
I don't know.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:34:19
You don't know how many people you asked for how they had a vote cards or campaign?
Gareth Hales
2:34:23
Well, obviously at the polling booth it just would have been the people that were there, and if I was
Shayne Neumann MP
2:34:29
Members of your congregation or various congregations.
Gareth Hales
2:34:33
Can I just ask is there any issue with encouraging people?
Shayne Neumann MP
2:34:37
No, well it's obvious in the evidence given by the Plymouth Brethren that there was a level of coordination but the church's evidence is that in fact there was no organised coordination by the church itself. But individuals may participate in this. Now you're a senior member of that congregation, The son of the most senior person in the in the world and I'm asking you a simple question Did you ask anyone in your congregation or congregation 82 of them around the country to? Participate in political campaigns Hannah had a vote cards campaign put up signs do anything and you can't give me a straight answer I'm just asking a simple question
Gareth Hales
2:35:18
I'm trying to give you a straight answer But you're asking me about five questions at once. They just ask me one question.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:35:24
I'll you, did you ask anyone?
Gareth Hales
2:35:29
No, the answer is.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:35:32
So. What did you mean by your early evidence about encouraging people and, you know, being on chat, you know, chat room conversation? What did you mean by that That's at odds with what you said earlier?
Gareth Hales
2:35:42
No, it's not. It's just people that were already campaigning. I was just encouraging them.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:35:47
How did they come to be already campaigning, Mr. Hales?
Gareth Hales
2:35:51
They. Are individual businessmen that a concern about the direction of the country and you are about the leadership.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:35:57
You were in a chat group with everyone that was campaigning.
Gareth Hales
2:36:02
No, not at all.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:36:04
So talk to us about your encouragement of their campaigning. Like how, how was it just one-on-one? Was it in a group? Like who were you encouraging and how were you encouraging them?
Gareth Hales
2:36:18
Well as I said I wasn't managing or directing or coordinating, there might have been a few millions I went to, just a general chat on how they...
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:36:25
Who were you encouraging and how were you encouraging them?
Gareth Hales
2:36:29
Well I can't give you names. I don't have a list of names of people that were there.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:36:34
Was it more than one person?
Gareth Hales
2:36:38
I couldn't say the exact number. It might have been five or six persons.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:36:41
Okay. And what did they do with that encouragement?
Gareth Hales
2:36:46
Well, Mr Laxale, What should issue with encourage?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:36:49
would you issue me My issue is, Mr Hales, is that we've had thousands and thousands of members of your church that have flooded polling booths across the country—
Ben Small MP
2:37:02
On what basis, Chair, on what basis do you make that allegation?
Andrew Gee MP
2:37:06
Stop interrupting.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:37:07
And that—
Ben Small MP
2:37:08
No, no, I'll interrupt all I like because under the standing orders—
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:37:11
You have just said that you've— Mr Small.
Andrew Gee MP
2:37:14
Show some respect and courtesy and follow the rules of the committee. Thank you and do it politely through the chair.
Ben Small MP
2:37:21
I am talking to the chair and I didn't hear you start with a point of order either Mr G. So pipe down.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:37:26
Thank you Mr Small, I'd like to ask a question. You'll note that I've ceded a lot of my time to other members of this committee and I'd like to ask a question to clarify this. You've given evidence, so your father's given evidence that he gave a sermon which encouraged people to be fervent in prayer about good government, right? Then there is an interpretation of that sermon in which you appeared in a video with your two other brothers.
Then you've just given evidence that you have encouraged people to turn up on polling booths and words have been used to the extent of, you know, let's get our ground game. You know, don't quote me exactly but was read out before, make sure our booths are manned. So there's a clear link here, and that is what we're interested in because there are rules and laws in this country about mass involvement in political campaigns and transparency around that.
That's why these questions are being asked. So it's important for us to understand, Mr Hales, to what extent you encouraged members of your church to participate in the 2025 election election at such scale across the country. Do you accept that? Do you expect these are reasonable questions to ask given that context?
Gareth Hales
2:38:44
Really, about the rules and laws, we didn't break any rules, we didn't break any laws, and you talk about thousands and thousands of people, how do you actually know that they were Brethren or members of Plymouth Brethren Church?
Shayne Neumann MP
2:38:59
Can I continue my question?
Gareth Hales
2:39:00
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
Did they wear signs or did they wear banners at the
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:39:04
It's been well documented Mr. Hales. Mr. Neumann. So, sorry, do you accept that it's reasonable, sorry, my question, which wasn't answered, so I know you did answer it, you said it wasn't acceptable for us to ask these questions. Okay, Mr Neumann.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:39:19
Can I then talk about this, any discussions, did you have, you met Sam Jackson-Hope and Peter Dutton at a petrol station, where was that?
Gareth Hales
2:39:30
I don't remember the exact petrol station, it was up at Carlingford near a little set of shops there.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:39:37
Okay, alright, prior to that meeting, did you have any discussions, telephone conversations or meetings with Sam Jackson-Hope or anyone in Peter Dutton's office about any activity concerning the election, federal election in 2025?
Gareth Hales
2:39:54
No, absolutely not, Mr Neumann.. I had no I had no telephone conversations with those people.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:39:59
So magically and mysteriously you just happened to have turned up to a petrol station where the leader of the opposition and his staff and there was a press event. How did that happen?
Gareth Hales
2:40:12
It wasn't magic or mysterious, it was just known that he was going to turn up there because he was giving a speech on fuel. A few, a tank of tanker there or something. There's lots of people. There was hundreds of people.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:40:26
How did you know, Mr Hales? I mean, I've been involved in lots of campaigns in 40 years of the Labor Party membership and 20 years in federal parliament nearly, and during federal campaigns, leaders don't often tell even the press gallery took quite life. How did you know about this event?
Gareth Hales
2:40:42
You heard Mr Neumann word of mouth.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:40:45
Word of mouth. So he told you, he told you, and then it went on, how did you know about this event? If you claim you're not involved in any campaigning?
Gareth Hales
2:40:54
I don't actually recall, but I dare say it was probably a friend of a friend.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:41:00
A friend of a friend told you about this event and Peter Dutton just happened to be there. And you had a conversation with Sam Jackson, who on media reports, was coordinating the activity of members of the Plymouth Brethren or participants in the church, who were in the campaign did you have any discussions within that day about the activities of you or any members of your congregation in any marginal seats around the country
Gareth Hales
2:41:27
No, not at all. I had no idea supposedly was a point of contact. I only found that later on in press articles.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:41:35
Okay, so you had no contact whatsoever with the Leader of the Opposition or his office or anyone associated with the Liberal campaign whatsoever, and nor did anyone in your church at the campaign.
Gareth Hales
2:41:49
Did you around a petrol station, yeah, so that was contact. Yeah, is that what you mean, or?
Shayne Neumann MP
2:41:55
Yes, well anything, no, you're not aware of any people in the leadership of your congregation having any contact with the Leader of the Opposition or the Liberal Party headquarters or Sam Hope or anyone at all? Not aware of that at all?
Gareth Hales
2:42:11
Respectfully, respectfully, Mr Neumann, I can't answer for them.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:42:15
But you're not aware of any activity, you're personally not aware of an activity?
Gareth Hales
2:42:19
No, I'm not aware.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:42:21
Okay. If you're not aware in relation to that, why did the Liberal Party review describe the Plymouth Brethren Church as a support group of the Liberal Party in the campaign? And did you take any steps to disabuse them of that statement?
Gareth Hales
2:42:39
I wasn't aware that the other Liberals regarded us.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:42:46
Regarded us? What do you mean by that?
Gareth Hales
2:42:50
Just as per your comment.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:42:53
So you just said regarded us. OK, what do you mean by that? Regarded the Plymouth Brethren members, the congregants that were there helping the Liberal Party and National Party?
Unidentified speaker
2:43:03
What did you mean by that?
Gareth Hales
2:43:03
Us? I'm not talking about Plymouth Brethren. I'm talking about concerned businessmen that may well have campaigned in their own electoral right.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:43:14
Well, no one's denying you've got a right to... I mean, I'm a member of a Baptist congregation. I don't deny anyone in my congregation has a right to campaign in election campaigns, but you just said about us. What did you mean by us?
Gareth Hales
2:43:29
You don't mind Baptist people participating in election, why are? You're so up about members of our church participating in election.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:43:39
Well, with respect to the members of the Baptist congregation or the Catholics, the Anglicans, didn't turn up in their thousands on polling booths or campaign activities. And I don't recall any sermons by any Baptist ministers being quoted on electronic billboards or by campaign workers on election day or pre-poll. That's why we're concerned about this issue, Mr Hales, and it's up to us to ask you questions, not you to ask us questions, with respect. So I'm asking you, what do you mean by us?
Ben Small MP
2:44:09
With respect, Chair, point of order, Mr Neumann is asking Mr Hales to account for the Liberal Party's report? That is completely unviable.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:44:19
Mr Small, the question was, what do you mean by us?
Ben Small MP
2:44:21
The original was to respond to the Liberal Party's report. He can't do that. So Mr Neumann can badger him all he likes.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:44:31
But I'm not doing that. I'm asking him to respond and clarify his own words.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:44:37
Yes, he's asking for a clarification on his own words.
Gareth Hales
2:44:40
You're making a big deal on us, us, these fellow Australians. We're all Australians here, and that's us.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:44:48
That's a very good interpretation of us. Is that what we really meant? Is that what we really meant?
Ben Small MP
2:44:56
Now Mr Neumann is trying perilously close to where Mr Gee was in making an accusation that the witness was just untruthful.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:45:02
Final question Mr Neumann, let's move on from that line of questioning. Thank you.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:45:07
Did you interpret Make. Australia happy, smiling and did you interpret that as a call to arms for political activity or did you think that your father was just talking about faith and fervency and prayer? Is that what you really truly believe?
Gareth Hales
2:45:25
Yeah, I said happy. I thought I could go back and be a happy dad,
Shayne Neumann MP
2:45:31
I guess. Can I find a final question? Mystified by you sawing these signs around pre-poll? You went to three pre-polls. Didn't you see any of these signs with your father's words being quoted at the pre -poll on polling booths around the place? Lots of polling booths, we've got them all around the country. Did you recall seeing that?
Gareth Hales
2:45:52
I didn't see any.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:45:53
Okay. All right.
Shayne Neumann MP
2:45:54
Thank you.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:45:55
Ms Payne.
Alicia Payne MP
2:45:58
you, Chair. Thank you, Mr Hales, for being in the committee today. We've obviously received countless reports in evidence to this committee and it's in the public reporting that members of your church participated in numbers and in a manner and a scale that has never been seen before in living memory at a federal election. What knowledge did you have of the national operations?
Gareth Hales
2:46:23
I had no knowledge of the national. Operations, and then the only way I found out are supposedly hundreds or thousands, whatever the numbers you're saying. I only found out that later on press articles written by Michael Bachelard.
Alicia Payne MP
2:46:39
But you were at those polling booths and there were numbers and numbers of people. Like we all saw it. There were people en masse and behaving in a coordinated manner Are you saying that that was just a coincidence that members of your church who don't normally vote and many hold a belief that they shouldn't vote just coincidentally showed up en masse all around the country at polling booths?
Gareth Hales
2:47:07
The few polls I went to, there wasn't members of the church, hardly any members there. There might have been 3 or 4. Most of the people I spoke to were not part of my church. They were just normal either dads and mums and their kids or it was just either Labor or Liberal campaigners.
Alicia Payne MP
2:47:26
Does the reported behaviour, which is outlined in the evidence, concern you?
Gareth Hales
2:47:35
If there's any behaviour that's poor or bad or harassment or intimidation, yeah, that concerns me; I don't agree with that.
Alicia Payne MP
2:47:42
And do you see any connection between... The video, the message that was sent by you and the actions of your members.
Unidentified speaker
2:47:55
the
Gareth Hales
2:47:58
video are you referring to?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:48:02
It's been reported and you've sought to take on notice the exact wording, but I don't, I was going to ask these clarifications at the end, but it's been reported following your father's sermon that it was streamed on GMS sent appeared alongside your by two brothers saying words to the effect of how good was that message on GMS, and then there were man the booths, you know, that our ground game on and you said you were going to talk about that video was then turned into a message, it's been reported. So were you in that video following your father's sermon, encouraging people to attend and man the boos on election?
Gareth Hales
2:48:55
I have to check the source of that. I don't think I was.
Alicia Payne MP
2:49:03
Okay, So you don't see any connection between that sermon and the actions of the members?
Gareth Hales
2:49:15
When my dad gives a sermon he's talking about the Bible and the Word of God and inspiring things about scripture. He doesn't refer to political events. He's just giving us the Word of God and yeah, just good things. Good scriptures, good subjects, good topics to talk about. We don't then fire up into election campaigns because of a one-line he says in his sermon. I mean that's. Honestly that is ridiculous. Like a one line that says, make Australia smile again or happy again.
Alicia Payne MP
2:49:48
But an interpretation was made in a video and what was that asking people to do?
Gareth Hales
2:49:59
Do you mean, interpretation? What do you mean by interpretation?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:50:01
Well, he's taken Well, he's taken the fact that he appeared on a video on notice. So let's see what the response is there.
Alicia Payne MP
2:50:07
Okay. Well, it's been reported that your father, Mr Bruce Hales, gave a sermon on Pauline Hanson and said, so I quote, so I hope that red haired lady gets a chance, more power to redheads. Have you interpreted that sermon?
Gareth Hales
2:50:24
How do you know he's referring to Pauline Hanson because she's got red hair, I guess?
Alicia Payne MP
2:50:31
No, I think it was, it was in the reports.
Gareth Hales
2:50:39
Just nicely, so what if my dad says something about someone with red hair, like really what is the big deal? And why are we talking about Pauline Hanson now? Like how she part of the 2025 election inquiry.
Alicia Payne MP
2:50:56
We're just interested how you and your church have interpreted that message, that sermon from Mr Bruce Hales.
Gareth Hales
2:51:06
I don't know how we interpret sermons. I'd suggest you come along for one of our meetings and listen to us take meetings. You might actually get some light as to who we are and what we do and what we think instead of just relying on Michael Bachelard's articles, which are full of lies.
Alicia Payne MP
2:51:27
Would you instruct your members to campaign at a federal election again?
Gareth Hales
2:51:34
I don't know. I mean I didn't instruct him anyway to campaign in this last one.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:51:41
Encourage.
Gareth Hales
2:51:42
Who knows what's around the corner.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:51:43
Don't know. You used the word encourage.
Gareth Hales
2:51:47
Encourage is not instruct. It. It's slightly different.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:51:52
Thanks, Ms Payne. Thank you. Lastly,, Mr G.
Andrew Gee MP
2:51:56
Mr Hales, thank you for your evidence today. I just want to take you back to this meeting at the golf club on the first of April 2025. I think your evidence was that Sante paid for that. Is that correct? The room for the meeting?
Gareth Hales
2:52:11
Correct.
Andrew Gee MP
2:52:12
And you, I think, agreed that there was a Morgan C Jonas there? Is that correct?
Gareth Hales
2:52:22
Morgan wasn't there.
Andrew Gee MP
2:52:24
So he wasn't there? Okay. Was Chris De Bruyne there?
Gareth Hales
2:52:32
No, Chris wasn't there.
Andrew Gee MP
2:52:34
Okay.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:52:35
Who was there?
Unidentified speaker
2:52:37
Mr Hales?
Gareth Hales
2:52:38
It was a business meeting, so it was some clients, it was It was customers, it was suppliers.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:52:45
So you know who, who you know who wasn't there, so who was there?
Gareth Hales
2:52:50
I don't recall, I'd have to get a list of names
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:52:53
So you have a recollection of who wasn't there but you don't have a recollection of who was there?
Gareth Hales
2:52:58
No, I just happen to know those two guys weren't there.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:53:02
If you could take that on notice, please.
Andrew Gee MP
2:53:04
Was Laurence McIntyre there, Mr Hales?
Gareth Hales
2:53:08
No. I don't know that name.
Andrew Gee MP
2:53:11
Harrison McLean. You know that person?
Gareth Hales
2:53:15
Don't know that name.
Andrew Gee MP
2:53:16
So, what sort of business meeting was it?
Gareth Hales
2:53:22
Sante. Just about deals, projects, clients, operations, project management.
Andrew Gee MP
2:53:31
Okay, so you booked a meeting at the golf club but you don't remember who was there?
Gareth Hales
2:53:37
I Just so you know, we have hundreds of meetings at this golf club. We use it regularly.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:53:44
It's a good golf club. It's in my lecture, it's fantastic. I'm not surprised you have meetings there.
Andrew Gee MP
2:53:49
Have you ever had any contact with Morgan C Jonas during the period of the federal election campaign in the lead up to the election? Section.
Gareth Hales
2:53:58
the more than once at my office.
Andrew Gee MP
2:54:01
And what's the nature of your relationship with him?
Gareth Hales
2:54:04
It was just a brief meeting. He wanted to talk to me about his wood-lopping business.
Andrew Gee MP
2:54:10
Sorry, his what business?
Gareth Hales
2:54:12
He touched on the campaign. He touched on some wood lopping business. And he touched on the campaign briefly and then he went and I never heard or saw of him again
Andrew Gee MP
2:54:23
and what what sort of conversation did you have with him about the campaign just
Gareth Hales
2:54:29
in the general direction that the government was heading and then geared nothing off from that.
Andrew Gee MP
2:54:35
Did you talk to him about campaigning in the 2025 federal election?
Gareth Hales
2:54:42
I was introduced by another business colleague. We had a meeting with him, I don't know what they were talking about, and I came in briefly. Probably had about a 20 minute discussion.
Andrew Gee MP
2:54:53
And Chris De Bruyne, do you know him?
Gareth Hales
2:54:58
Yes, I was introduced to him by one of my colleagues.
Andrew Gee MP
2:55:02
And what's the nature of the relationship with him that you have?
Gareth Hales
2:55:06
I don't really have a relationship with him. I met him twice, briefly.
Andrew Gee MP
2:55:10
Where did you meet him?
Gareth Hales
2:55:11
Yeah, briefly, he's just met him here at the office.
Andrew Gee MP
2:55:15
Twice.
Gareth Hales
2:55:21
he wanted to ask me some advice about his business, but then he spoke briefly about the campaign, but then I never heard or saw of him again. I've got no personal relationship with him. I've got no business relationship with him.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:55:33
What business did he ask about?
Gareth Hales
2:55:38
I can't remember. I think he's self-employed.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:55:43
Does Australian Firebrand ring a bell? Does Australian Firebrand ring a bell?
Gareth Hales
2:55:49
No, it doesn't.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:55:51
So he wasn't asking you about advice for his business, Australian Firebrand. Is that your evidence?
Gareth Hales
2:55:56
No, it wasn't.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:55:57
Okay.
Gareth Hales
2:55:58
I don't recall Firebrand. No.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:56:00
Sorry, you don't recall or he wasn't? Which one is it?
Gareth Hales
2:56:05
No, I don't. Haven't heard. This is the first time I've heard of Firebrand.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:56:08
Okay.
Andrew Gee MP
2:56:11
Are you aware that Mr De Bruyne is a far-right wing activist?
Gareth Hales
2:56:16
No, I wasn't aware of that.
Andrew Gee MP
2:56:18
Or Morgan C Jonas, who is associated with the Freedom Party of Victoria?
Gareth Hales
2:56:23
No, I didn't know that.
Andrew Gee MP
2:56:25
I recall seeing Mr Jonas's name authorising core flutes and placards in the electorate of Calare, are you aware he was doing that in the federal election campaign?
Gareth Hales
2:56:38
No, I wasn't aware at all.
Andrew Gee MP
2:56:40
Right. Were you aware that former Liberal Party cabinet minister, Linda Reynolds, has stated publicly that she was approached by members of the Plymouth Brethren Church to get access to the Liberal Party's database called Feedback. Were you aware of that?
Gareth Hales
2:57:05
No, and I've never heard of Linda Reynolds.
Andrew Gee MP
2:57:08
Okay, does that, would that concern you though, having heard about it for the first time today, that Ms Reynolds has written that she was approached by members of your church during the campaign to get access to the Liberal Party's database called Feedback. Were you aware, does that concern you that that happened?
Gareth Hales
2:57:27
Would it concern me?
Andrew Gee MP
2:57:31
Did it, does it concern you that members of your church were trying to get access to the AEC database?
Gareth Hales
2:57:39
Doesn't really concern me because I didn't know about it.
Andrew Gee MP
2:57:42
Yeah, but knowing about it now, does that concern you that you had members of your
Ben Small MP
2:57:47
Point of order, Chair. Point of order, Chair. The terms of reference are about the previous election, not about what any witness might think about reports in last week's paper.
Andrew Gee MP
2:57:56
Well, that's what... I'm sorry.
Ben Small MP
2:57:58
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
You've allowed this to stray so far off the reservation, buddy.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:57:59
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
Mr Small, Mr Small, Mr Small, the Deputy Chair was asking in his first questions to this inquiry about news articles from about a week, or a fortnight ago. If it's good enough for the Deputy Chair, it's good enough for Mr G.
Andrew Gee MP
2:58:16
And quite frankly the piece that Reynolds has written for the Sydney Morning Herald, says that in the final weeks of the 2025 federal election campaign, which correct me if I'm wrong is what we're dealing with here today, she says she was approached by two members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church because she knew them to be members and they wanted access to the AEC database. So does that concern you Mr Hales?
Ben Small MP
2:58:40
But what makes it that she knows that anyone is a member of the church?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:58:44
Mr Small, the question's not of you, it's of Mr Hales.
Andrew Gee MP
2:58:47
So just pipe down and let the witness answer the question please.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:58:54
Yeah.
Unidentified speaker
2:58:55
Can't
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
2:58:54
I would love you to speak.
Gareth Hales
2:58:57
I can't answer for them.
Andrew Gee MP
2:58:59
I'm not asking you to, Mr Hales, I'm asking you, the question was, Mr Hales, does it concern you that I'm telling you now that Ms Reynolds was approached by two members of the Brethren Church during the final weeks of the 2025 federal election campaign to get access to the AEC database that is held by the Liberal Party. It's called feedback.
Gareth Hales
2:59:23
Happy to look into it. I don't know anything about it.
Andrew Gee MP
2:59:25
Does it concern you, Mr Hales? Does it concern you, Mr Hales, that was the question.
Gareth Hales
2:59:32
It just doesn't concern me because I didn't know about it. And now you've brought it up, you think I should be concerned? I'll look into it for you I'm back... [unclear]
Andrew Gee MP
2:59:40
Does it concern you, given that you've said that no members of the church were engaged in coordinating in partisan electioneering, does it concern you that two members of your church were approaching a former cabinet minister in the Liberal National government to get access to the AEC database?
Ben Small MP
3:00:02
Yeah, this question should be taken on notice
Andrew Gee MP
3:00:04
Could you stop, could you stop interrupting please, Mr Small. It's highly disrespectful and against the rules of this committee.
Ben Small MP
3:00:10
Point of order, when the question has been taken on notice under [unclear]
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:00:14
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
But that's, that's for Mr Hales to determine, Mr Small, not you. Let him decide whether he answers a question or whether he doesn't. You're not here to answer questions on behalf of Mr Hales or the Plymouth Brethren.. They are. They are.
Ben Small MP
3:00:30
[indecipherable]
Andrew Gee MP
3:00:31
Then why don't you abide by them instead of running a protection racket for a witness? Now, let's get on with it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:00:36
I'm here to abide by the standing orders, Mr Small, and make judgements, not you. So, I would like Mr G to ask his question again and for Mr Hales to either answer it or Take it on notice as per the standing orders without interruption please we've established that the questionings in order and it has been since the start of this inquiry for government and non-government members.
Andrew Gee MP
3:00:59
Mr Hales, does it concern you that I'm telling you now that Ms Reynolds a former Liberal Party cabinet minister says that she was approached by two members of your church to get access to the AEC database?
Gareth Hales
3:01:14
Yes now you've asked me questions three times I'm happy to take it on notice.
Andrew Gee MP
3:01:19
So it does concern you?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:01:21
He's taken it on notice, Mr Gee.
Gareth Hales
3:01:22
Yes, it concerns me.
Gareth Hales
3:01:23
It clearly concerns you, so therefore I'll mirror and reflect your concern.
Andrew Gee MP
3:01:29
Well, Mr Hales, quite frankly, I think that this issue concerns the whole Australian-public. If members of your church are being given access, to the Australian Electoral Commission database, I think that is an issue of national concern. It's not just me, Mr Hales. You aware that...
Gareth Hales
3:01:48
Once again, once again, I'll take it on notice.
Andrew Gee MP
3:01:51
Were any members of your church, Mr Hales, engaging in telephone canvassing during the 2025 federal election campaign that you're aware of?
Gareth Hales
3:02:04
I wasn't aware of it at the time and I did see a press article, might have been months later, something about it. That's all I know about it.
Andrew Gee MP
3:02:14
Did you carry out any investigations as to what your, the members of your church were doing, telephone canvassing and the nature of their canvassing when you read those reports?
Gareth Hales
3:02:25
No, because that's not my role. I don't have an official role in the church. I believe you had Lloyd Grimshaw on camera a few weeks ago and that'd be a question directed to him. That's his role.
Andrew Gee MP
3:02:40
Would you personally be concerned though if members of the Brethren Church were telephone canvassing on behalf of the Liberal or National parties during the 2025 Federal election campaign?
Gareth Hales
3:02:52
Yes, well now you've said concern five times, yes. I'm very concerned.
Andrew Gee MP
3:02:59
Mr Hales, your evidence before this committee is that you just essentially appeared at polling booths to participate in election campaigns. And There was no coordination or direction or any activity of that nature on behalf of the church. That's your evidence isn't it?
Gareth Hales
3:03:26
100%. There was no coordination and no direction from the church.
Andrew Gee MP
3:03:31
Can you understand Mr Hales, how someone in my position, views your evidence with a great deal of scepticism, given that I personally saw a members of your church following
Ben Small MP
3:03:43
Point of order, Chair, Chair, Chair. We have been through this. This is an accusation of untruthfulness at the most generous. We are now at 12 minutes of this nonsense, which is twice as long as the Coalition have had. This has got to stop.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:03:59
He's a non-government member, if you could just ask the question without the reflection.
Andrew Gee MP
3:04:04
Can you understand And how someone in my position views that with scepticism, given that I saw members of your church following me around en masse during the federal election campaign in numbers. Do you understand how someone like me would be sceptical about that?
Gareth Hales
3:04:21
Yes, I hear you and I understand your frustration.
Andrew Gee MP
3:04:24
And what action are you going to take over that?
Gareth Hales
3:04:29
What action would you like me to take?
Andrew Gee MP
3:04:31
I'm asking you what action you're going to take
Ben Small MP
3:04:35
Hang on, hang on, again, standing orders, relevance to the terms of inquiry What is going on here, Chair?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:04:42
We're talking
Ben Small MP
3:04:43
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
[unclear]
Andrew Gee MP
3:04:44
[Crosstalk: more than one person is speaking at once here, so this passage is unclear and may be wrong.]
think we're hitting a chord with the Liberal Party is what's going on
Ben Small MP
3:04:46
he doesn't have a formal role in the church that you allowed the imputation of lying just now and then he is badgering this witness when he says he does not have a formal role What is going on here?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:04:58
Mr Small, he's... Mr Gee is asking about behaviour at the 2025 election at his own seat...
Ben Small MP
3:05:03
Nobody's asking...
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:05:04
Yeah, and he's asking... yeah, and I think that's a fair question. It's a fair question. That's a fair question. Given it's about behaviour at the 2025 election, which is, which is point number one of our terms of reference so again it's up to Mr Hales if that's his answer that's his answer but let him answer again please, Mr Small. You seem to be answering questions on behalf of the church, when you're a member of this inquiry, not the witness giving evidence. So please let the witness answer the question.
Gareth Hales
3:05:39
Let me, can I answer the question now?
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:05:41
I would love you to answer the question, Mr. Hales.
Gareth Hales
3:05:43
Okay. I'm sorry that you're frustrated and upset. I don't have a formal role in the PBCC, and I'm happy to take it on question and pass it on to the relevant directors, who would probably be Lloyd Grimshaw.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:05:57
Last question, Mr Gee.
Andrew Gee MP
3:05:58
Mr Hales, during the 2025 federal election campaign, the evidence before this committee is that members of the church, in the thousands, were engaged in political campaigning on behalf of the Liberal, National and also One Nation parties. It just defies belief. It just defies, but your den. Your denials, Mr. Hales and that of your father, that the church had no role in coordinating any of these people and that everyone just miraculously turned up and engaged in that activity just defies belief. Can you understand how people find that whole line, which you're asking us to buy, very difficult to believe?
Ben Small MP
3:06:47
Point of order. At the risk of being like a broken record—
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:06:52
Mr Small.
Ben Small MP
3:06:53
Mr Gee has just alleged. That the witness has been lying. That is a most egregious breach of the standing orders. I would ask that the question, if there is such a thing in there, be rephrased.
Andrew Gee MP
3:07:05
That's not what I've been asking at all.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:07:07
I interpreted the question as Mr Gee trying to understand the juxtaposition between the evidence this committee has received, the reporting in the public domain, and the evidence of the church. I think that is a reasonable question to ask given it is in regards to the 2025 federal elections. So this is the last question, Mr Small. I'd ask that you not jump in again and let Mr Hales answer the question.
Andrew Gee MP
3:07:31
It's the old Liberal Party protection racket. Can you answer the question, Mr Hales?
Ben Small MP
3:07:34
No, no, no, no, no, I'm not going to let that go unchecked
Ben Small MP
3:07:37
I will be writing to the chair of committees to have this Hansard reviewed.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:07:37
Can you withdraw that, please?
Ben Small MP
3:07:41
I will be writing to the chair of committees to have this Hansard reviewed, and Mr Gee might think that's hilarious.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:07:47
Could you withdraw that please?
Andrew Gee MP
3:07:48
I'll withdraw it. I'll withdraw it.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:07:50
He's withdrawn.
Ben Small MP
3:07:51
let that garbage go unchecked on him.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:07:53
He's withdrawn that comment, Mr Small.
Andrew Gee MP
3:07:58
So, Mr Hales, can you answer the question, please?
Gareth Hales
3:08:01
Just ask the question again and I'll answer it.
Andrew Gee MP
3:08:03
Given that the evidence before this committee is that thousands of members of your church actively participated in a coordinated way in the 2025 federal election Campaign. Can you understand how people might find the church's denial that it had any role in coordinating or directing any of those members is very difficult to believe. It defies belief.
Gareth Hales
3:08:30
I understand it's difficult to believe, but they weren't members of the church. They were members of concerned business groups and members of private citizens. They weren't there on behalf of the church.
Andrew Gee MP
3:08:42
Thank you, Mr Hales. I for one am not buying what you are selling, but I do appreciate you giving evidence today.
Jerome Laxale MP (Chair)
3:08:47
Mr Hales, thank you for your attendance here today. You'll be sent a copy of the transcript of your evidence to assist you with answering questions taken on notice today and you'll have an opportunity to request corrections to transcription errors. Members also have seven days to submit more questions on notice as resolved by this committee. Once you've received the transcript you are asked to provide responses to any questions on notice within two weeks. Please forward these and any additional information that has been requested.
Ms Ryan, if you— Dr Ryan, if you could just stay for a minute, please. To the Secretariat. Please know that the responses to questions on notice will be published on the committee's website as submissions to the inquiry. I declare this meeting closed. Thank you, Mr Hales. Members, you could just
Reader Alerts